Account remaining terminated despite DMCA strike removal

My account “kruzzle” was recently dmca’d which caused it to be terminated. Upon my successful counter going through and the asset that caused my termination being restored my account remains terminated. I asked many times for them to provide me with the assets that caused my account to get terminated and to restore it and they keep denying my request every time I ask.

I should have gotten unterminated immediately after my counter strike went through and my asset was restored.


(Me asking them to restore my account & to provide what assets caused my strike)


Expected behavior

I should obviously be informed what strikes were placed upon my account and the assets in question that were striked, when an asset is restored the users account should have the moderation action revoked as well.

A private message is associated with this bug report

7 Likes

wouldnt the ban be because you repeated the action?
i doubt at roblox’s current state they would unban your account even though you appealed it.

1 Like

No, that response is given to everyone when they hit 3 strikes and try to appeal NORMALLY without countering

2 Likes

Oh I see then. I’m not sure why they would take down a sitting emote unless it actually was infringing an emote from another game

1 Like

Roblox themselves weren’t the ones that dmca’d it, I had comissioned someone to animate it for me and apparently they stole it, upon talking with the actual animator they revoked the strike as I obviously had no idea so it was sorted out

2 Likes

Why would an animator steal an animation (if I assume from the comission) they were getting paid?

Still unfortunate you got banned for something someone else did. Hope you get your account back.

1 Like

The originally animator had dmca’d me and I had gotten scammed when commissioning someone to animate for me, thank you though

2 Likes

Something happened similar to me. I was terminated for multiple items deleted, one was appealed but I didn’t get unterminated, just send another support ticket for the account and say the system didn’t update your ban.

2 Likes

I emailed copyright agents multiple times and they all reply with the same message

1 Like

Help this dude out yall shouldn’t treat the people that make the catalog what it is nowadays get such harsh punishments

1 Like

@starhiker13 review this if possible, im stuck

1 Like

It’s crazy to me that Roblox accepts DMCA requests for simple movements like this, because they don’t even fall under DMCA. :sob::folded_hands:t2: Copyright around choreography and pantomime is already limited enough, so having to send a counter notice for a basic sitting animation is absolutely ridiculous. First of all, Roblox should address this.


Secondly, I think the copyright agent already explained the reason for your ban in the ticket in a reasonable context, so you’re probably not getting unbanned. The repeat infringer policy is something Roblox takes seriously. If you receive multiple strikes, Roblox reserves the right to terminate your account. Even if you countered one of them, there are still two strikes on your account.

For more information about the repeat infringer policy:
https://en.help.roblox.com/hc/en-us/articles/115004647846-Roblox-Terms-of-Use#access-to-services (User Terms 2(e))

https://en.help.roblox.com/hc/en-us/articles/115004647846-Roblox-Terms-of-Use#intellectual-property (Creator Terms 2(b)(vii))

1 Like

There’s nothing to debate here, 3 stikes = termination and 2 strikes does not, im not gonna sit here and try to prove a point that doesn’t need to be proven

1 Like

DMCA agents will say you’re a repeat infringer even if you countered a strike, they lack consistency and it isn’t unusual that you have to explain the situation for weeks on end for them to understand. It took me close to a month to appeal an account this happened to, and for some of my other friends they never received a resolution even though they had countered strikes and restored assets. DMCA agents are incompetent and lack the resources necessary to handle the traffic flowing in and out of their department and it honestly needs to be overhauled. This is not the first or the last time this has happened. And of course, attempting to explain the situation to an agent which is supposed to help will often result in “we cannot provide anymore information.”

7 Likes

@starhiker13 Would really like this reviewed, thanks!

2 Likes