AnimationIds Mysteriously Changing to Pre-Change Values

Help and Feedback Scripting Support
,
#1

  1. What do you want to achieve? Keep it simple and clear!
    I want to change default animations depending on the character the player is playing as. Each character model contains a StringValue denoting the character. I have edited the default animation script to accommodate this and created a ServerScript to change the AnimationIds for loaded characters.

  2. What is the issue? Include screenshots/videos if possible!
    The AnimationIds change for a split second before reverting back to whatever they were before being changed; therefore, the animations remain the same.

    image
    image833×44 14.7 KB

    “rbxassetid://656117400” is right, but it changes back to its original value before you can even read this one in the properties window.

  3. What solutions have you tried so far? Did you look for solutions on the Developer Hub?
    I’ve scavenged the forum for four days and haven’t been able to resolve the issue. That’s why I’m here.

  4. The before-you-asks:

  • Yes, animation priorities, at least for Sammy, are correct, and even putting animations as top-priority (“Action”) has no effect, so priorities are not the likely culprit.
  • Yes, the IDs are valid and confirmed. Sammy’s IDs are literally from an R15 animation pack.
  • Yes, the humanoid is set to R15.
  • Yes, the variables are correct.
  • Yes, I can change the AnimationIds manually by using the Properties tab while testing, but as you know, I can’t do that in an actual game! Might be useful info, though.
  • Yes, the conditionals are correct and run.
  • Yes, Output is error-free.

The ServerScript in ServerScriptStorage:

local players = game:GetService("Players")
local repStorage = game:GetService("ReplicatedStorage")

players.PlayerAdded:Connect(function(player)
	player.CharacterAdded:Connect(function(chara)
		local animScript = chara.Animate
		for _, child in pairs(chara.Humanoid:GetPlayingAnimationTracks()) do
			child:Stop()
		end

		local char = chara:WaitForChild("Character").Value
		local idle1 = animScript:WaitForChild("idle").Animation1.AnimationId
		local idle2 = animScript:WaitForChild("idle").Animation2.AnimationId
		local jump = animScript:WaitForChild("jump").JumpAnim.AnimationId
		local fall = animScript:WaitForChild("fall").FallAnim.AnimationId
		local climb = animScript:WaitForChild("climb").ClimbAnim.AnimationId
		local run = animScript:WaitForChild("run").RunAnim.AnimationId
		local walk = animScript:WaitForChild("walk").WalkAnim.AnimationId

		if char == "Kindoodle" then
			idle1 = "rbxassetid://5230599789"
			idle2 = "rbxassetid://5230599789"
			jump = "rbxassetid://782847020"
			fall = "rbxassetid://782846423"
			climb = "rbxassetid://782843869"
			run = "rbxassetid://782842708"
			walk = "rbxassetid://782843345"
		elseif char == "Sammy" then -- for testing, StarterCharacter = Sammy
			print(char) -- prints fine
			idle1 = "rbxassetid://656117400"
			print(idle1) -- prints correct ID, but the ID switches back to the default shortly after 3:
			idle2 = "rbxassetid://656118341"
			jump = "rbxassetid://656117878"
			fall = "rbxassetid://656115606"
			climb = "rbxassetid://656114359"
			run = "rbxassetid://656118852"
			walk = "rbxassetid://656121766"
		elseif char == "Adamoy" then
			idle1 = "rbxassetid://6749849144"
			idle2 = "rbxassetid://6749849144"
			walk = "http://www.roblox.com/asset/?id=6749385835"
			run = "http://www.roblox.com/asset/?id=6749385835"
		elseif char == "Table" then
			idle1 = ""
			idle2 = ""
			walk = "rbxassetid://6770217690"
			run = "rbxassetid://6770217690"
		end
		repStorage.animsSet:FireClient(player)
	end)
end)

The LocalScript in StarterCharacterScripts:

game:GetService("ReplicatedStorage").animsSet.OnClientEvent:Wait()

local Figure = script.Parent
local Humanoid = Figure:WaitForChild("Humanoid")
local pose = "Standing"

local idle1 = script:WaitForChild("idle").Animation1.AnimationId
local idle2 = script:WaitForChild("idle").Animation2.AnimationId
local jump = script:WaitForChild("jump").JumpAnim.AnimationId
local fall = script:WaitForChild("fall").FallAnim.AnimationId
local climb = script:WaitForChild("climb").ClimbAnim.AnimationId
local run = script:WaitForChild("run").RunAnim.AnimationId
local walk = script:WaitForChild("walk").WalkAnim.AnimationId

local currentAnim = ""
local currentAnimInstance = nil
local currentAnimTrack = nil
local currentAnimKeyframeHandler = nil
local currentAnimSpeed = 1.0
local animTable = {}
local animNames = { 
	idle = 	{	
				{ id = idle1, weight = 9 },
				{ id = idle2, weight = 1 }
			},
	walk = 	{ 	
		{ id = walk, weight = 10 } 
			}, 
	run = 	{
		{ id = run, weight = 10 } 
			}, 
	jump = 	{
				{ id = jump, weight = 10 } 
			}, 
	fall = 	{
				{ id = fall, weight = 10 } 
			}, 
	climb = {
				{ id = climb, weight = 10 } 
			}, 
	sit = 	{
				{ id = "http://www.roblox.com/asset/?id=178130996", weight = 10 } 
			},	
	toolnone = {
				{ id = "http://www.roblox.com/asset/?id=182393478", weight = 10 } 
			},
	toolslash = {
				{ id = "http://www.roblox.com/asset/?id=129967390", weight = 10 } 
--				{ id = "slash.xml", weight = 10 } 
			},
	toollunge = {
				{ id = "http://www.roblox.com/asset/?id=129967478", weight = 10 } 
			},
	wave = {
				{ id = "http://www.roblox.com/asset/?id=128777973", weight = 10 } 
			},
	point = {
				{ id = "http://www.roblox.com/asset/?id=128853357", weight = 10 } 
			},
	dance1 = {
				{ id = "http://www.roblox.com/asset/?id=182435998", weight = 10 }, 
				{ id = "http://www.roblox.com/asset/?id=182491037", weight = 10 }, 
				{ id = "http://www.roblox.com/asset/?id=182491065", weight = 10 } 
			},
	dance2 = {
				{ id = "http://www.roblox.com/asset/?id=182436842", weight = 10 }, 
				{ id = "http://www.roblox.com/asset/?id=182491248", weight = 10 }, 
				{ id = "http://www.roblox.com/asset/?id=182491277", weight = 10 } 
			},
	dance3 = {
				{ id = "http://www.roblox.com/asset/?id=182436935", weight = 10 }, 
				{ id = "http://www.roblox.com/asset/?id=182491368", weight = 10 }, 
				{ id = "http://www.roblox.com/asset/?id=182491423", weight = 10 } 
			},
	laugh = {
				{ id = "http://www.roblox.com/asset/?id=129423131", weight = 10 } 
			},
	cheer = {
				{ id = "http://www.roblox.com/asset/?id=129423030", weight = 10 } 
			},
}
local dances = {"dance1", "dance2", "dance3"}

-- Existance in this list signifies that it is an emote, the value indicates if it is a looping emote
local emoteNames = { wave = false, point = false, dance1 = true, dance2 = true, dance3 = true, laugh = false, cheer = false}

function configureAnimationSet(name, fileList)
	if (animTable[name] ~= nil) then
		for _, connection in pairs(animTable[name].connections) do
			connection:disconnect()
		end
	end
	animTable[name] = {}
	animTable[name].count = 0
	animTable[name].totalWeight = 0	
	animTable[name].connections = {}

	-- check for config values
	local config = script:FindFirstChild(name)
	if (config ~= nil) then
--		print("Loading anims " .. name)
		table.insert(animTable[name].connections, config.ChildAdded:connect(function(child) configureAnimationSet(name, fileList) end))
		table.insert(animTable[name].connections, config.ChildRemoved:connect(function(child) configureAnimationSet(name, fileList) end))
		local idx = 1
		for _, childPart in pairs(config:GetChildren()) do
			if (childPart:IsA("Animation")) then
				table.insert(animTable[name].connections, childPart.Changed:connect(function(property) configureAnimationSet(name, fileList) end))
				animTable[name][idx] = {}
				animTable[name][idx].anim = childPart
				local weightObject = childPart:FindFirstChild("Weight")
				if (weightObject == nil) then
					animTable[name][idx].weight = 1
				else
					animTable[name][idx].weight = weightObject.Value
				end
				animTable[name].count = animTable[name].count + 1
				animTable[name].totalWeight = animTable[name].totalWeight + animTable[name][idx].weight
	--			print(name .. " [" .. idx .. "] " .. animTable[name][idx].anim.AnimationId .. " (" .. animTable[name][idx].weight .. ")")
				idx = idx + 1
			end
		end
	end

	-- fallback to defaults
	if (animTable[name].count <= 0) then
		for idx, anim in pairs(fileList) do
			animTable[name][idx] = {}
			animTable[name][idx].anim = Instance.new("Animation")
			animTable[name][idx].anim.Name = name
			animTable[name][idx].anim.AnimationId = anim.id
			animTable[name][idx].weight = anim.weight
			animTable[name].count = animTable[name].count + 1
			animTable[name].totalWeight = animTable[name].totalWeight + anim.weight
--			print(name .. " [" .. idx .. "] " .. anim.id .. " (" .. anim.weight .. ")")
		end
	end
end

-- Setup animation objects
function scriptChildModified(child)
	local fileList = animNames[child.Name]
	if (fileList ~= nil) then
		configureAnimationSet(child.Name, fileList)
	end	
end

script.ChildAdded:connect(scriptChildModified)
script.ChildRemoved:connect(scriptChildModified)


for name, fileList in pairs(animNames) do 
	configureAnimationSet(name, fileList)
end	

-- ANIMATION

-- declarations
local toolAnim = "None"
local toolAnimTime = 0

local jumpAnimTime = 0
local jumpAnimDuration = 0.3

local toolTransitionTime = 0.1
local fallTransitionTime = 0.3
local jumpMaxLimbVelocity = 0.75

-- functions

function stopAllAnimations()
	local oldAnim = currentAnim

	-- return to idle if finishing an emote
	if (emoteNames[oldAnim] ~= nil and emoteNames[oldAnim] == false) then
		oldAnim = "idle"
	end

	currentAnim = ""
	currentAnimInstance = nil
	if (currentAnimKeyframeHandler ~= nil) then
		currentAnimKeyframeHandler:disconnect()
	end

	if (currentAnimTrack ~= nil) then
		currentAnimTrack:Stop()
		currentAnimTrack:Destroy()
		currentAnimTrack = nil
	end
	return oldAnim
end

function setAnimationSpeed(speed)
	if speed ~= currentAnimSpeed then
		currentAnimSpeed = speed
		currentAnimTrack:AdjustSpeed(currentAnimSpeed)
	end
end

function keyFrameReachedFunc(frameName)
	if (frameName == "End") then

		local repeatAnim = currentAnim
		-- return to idle if finishing an emote
		if (emoteNames[repeatAnim] ~= nil and emoteNames[repeatAnim] == false) then
			repeatAnim = "idle"
		end
		
		local animSpeed = currentAnimSpeed
		playAnimation(repeatAnim, 0.0, Humanoid)
		setAnimationSpeed(animSpeed)
	end
end

-- Preload animations
function playAnimation(animName, transitionTime, humanoid) 
		
	local roll = math.random(1, animTable[animName].totalWeight) 
	local origRoll = roll
	local idx = 1
	while (roll > animTable[animName][idx].weight) do
		roll = roll - animTable[animName][idx].weight
		idx = idx + 1
	end
--		print(animName .. " " .. idx .. " [" .. origRoll .. "]")
	local anim = animTable[animName][idx].anim

	-- switch animation		
	if (anim ~= currentAnimInstance) then
		
		if (currentAnimTrack ~= nil) then
			currentAnimTrack:Stop(transitionTime)
			currentAnimTrack:Destroy()
		end

		currentAnimSpeed = 1.0
	
		-- load it to the humanoid; get AnimationTrack
		currentAnimTrack = humanoid:LoadAnimation(anim)
		currentAnimTrack.Priority = Enum.AnimationPriority.Core
		 
		-- play the animation
		currentAnimTrack:Play(transitionTime)
		currentAnim = animName
		currentAnimInstance = anim

		-- set up keyframe name triggers
		if (currentAnimKeyframeHandler ~= nil) then
			currentAnimKeyframeHandler:disconnect()
		end
		currentAnimKeyframeHandler = currentAnimTrack.KeyframeReached:connect(keyFrameReachedFunc)
		
	end

end

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

local toolAnimName = ""
local toolAnimTrack = nil
local toolAnimInstance = nil
local currentToolAnimKeyframeHandler = nil

function toolKeyFrameReachedFunc(frameName)
	if (frameName == "End") then
--		print("Keyframe : ".. frameName)	
		playToolAnimation(toolAnimName, 0.0, Humanoid)
	end
end


function playToolAnimation(animName, transitionTime, humanoid, priority)	 
		
		local roll = math.random(1, animTable[animName].totalWeight) 
		local origRoll = roll
		local idx = 1
		while (roll > animTable[animName][idx].weight) do
			roll = roll - animTable[animName][idx].weight
			idx = idx + 1
		end
--		print(animName .. " * " .. idx .. " [" .. origRoll .. "]")
		local anim = animTable[animName][idx].anim

		if (toolAnimInstance ~= anim) then
			
			if (toolAnimTrack ~= nil) then
				toolAnimTrack:Stop()
				toolAnimTrack:Destroy()
				transitionTime = 0
			end
					
			-- load it to the humanoid; get AnimationTrack
			toolAnimTrack = humanoid:LoadAnimation(anim)
			if priority then
				toolAnimTrack.Priority = priority
			end
			 
			-- play the animation
			toolAnimTrack:Play(transitionTime)
			toolAnimName = animName
			toolAnimInstance = anim

			currentToolAnimKeyframeHandler = toolAnimTrack.KeyframeReached:connect(toolKeyFrameReachedFunc)
		end
end

function stopToolAnimations()
	local oldAnim = toolAnimName

	if (currentToolAnimKeyframeHandler ~= nil) then
		currentToolAnimKeyframeHandler:disconnect()
	end

	toolAnimName = ""
	toolAnimInstance = nil
	if (toolAnimTrack ~= nil) then
		toolAnimTrack:Stop()
		toolAnimTrack:Destroy()
		toolAnimTrack = nil
	end


	return oldAnim
end

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


function onRunning(speed)
	if speed > 0.01 then
		playAnimation("walk", 0.1, Humanoid)
		if currentAnimInstance and currentAnimInstance.AnimationId == "http://www.roblox.com/asset/?id=6749385835" then
			setAnimationSpeed(speed / 14.5)
		end
		pose = "Running"
	else
		if emoteNames[currentAnim] == nil then
			playAnimation("idle", 0.1, Humanoid)
			pose = "Standing"
		end
	end
end

function onDied()
	pose = "Dead"
end

function onJumping()
	playAnimation("jump", 0.1, Humanoid)
	jumpAnimTime = jumpAnimDuration
	pose = "Jumping"
end

function onClimbing(speed)
	playAnimation("climb", 0.1, Humanoid)
	setAnimationSpeed(speed / 12.0)
	pose = "Climbing"
end

function onGettingUp()
	pose = "GettingUp"
end

function onFreeFall()
	if (jumpAnimTime <= 0) then
		playAnimation("fall", fallTransitionTime, Humanoid)
	end
	pose = "FreeFall"
end

function onFallingDown()
	pose = "FallingDown"
end

function onSeated()
	pose = "Seated"
end

function onPlatformStanding()
	pose = "PlatformStanding"
end

function onSwimming(speed)
	if speed > 0 then
		pose = "Running"
	else
		pose = "Standing"
	end
end

function getTool()	
	for _, kid in ipairs(Figure:GetChildren()) do
		if kid.className == "Tool" then return kid end
	end
	return nil
end

function getToolAnim(tool)
	for _, c in ipairs(tool:GetChildren()) do
		if c.Name == "toolanim" and c.className == "StringValue" then
			return c
		end
	end
	return nil
end

function animateTool()
	
	if (toolAnim == "None") then
		playToolAnimation("toolnone", toolTransitionTime, Humanoid, Enum.AnimationPriority.Idle)
		return
	end

	if (toolAnim == "Slash") then
		playToolAnimation("toolslash", 0, Humanoid, Enum.AnimationPriority.Action)
		return
	end

	if (toolAnim == "Lunge") then
		playToolAnimation("toollunge", 0, Humanoid, Enum.AnimationPriority.Action)
		return
	end
end

--function moveSit()
--	RightShoulder.MaxVelocity = 0.15
--	LeftShoulder.MaxVelocity = 0.15
--	RightShoulder:SetDesiredAngle(3.14 /2)
--	LeftShoulder:SetDesiredAngle(-3.14 /2)
--	RightHip:SetDesiredAngle(3.14 /2)
--	LeftHip:SetDesiredAngle(-3.14 /2)
--end

local lastTick = 0

function move(time)
	local amplitude = 1
	local frequency = 1
  	local deltaTime = time - lastTick
  	lastTick = time

	local climbFudge = 0
	local setAngles = false

  	if (jumpAnimTime > 0) then
  		jumpAnimTime = jumpAnimTime - deltaTime
  	end

	if (pose == "FreeFall" and jumpAnimTime <= 0) then
		playAnimation("fall", fallTransitionTime, Humanoid)
	elseif (pose == "Seated") then
		playAnimation("sit", 0.5, Humanoid)
		return
	elseif (pose == "Running") then
		playAnimation("walk", 0.1, Humanoid)
	elseif (pose == "Dead" or pose == "GettingUp" or pose == "FallingDown" or pose == "Seated" or pose == "PlatformStanding") then
--		print("Wha " .. pose)
		stopAllAnimations()
		amplitude = 0.1
		frequency = 1
		setAngles = true
	end

	--if (setAngles) then
	--	local desiredAngle = amplitude * math.sin(time * frequency)

	--	RightShoulder:SetDesiredAngle(desiredAngle + climbFudge)
	--	LeftShoulder:SetDesiredAngle(desiredAngle - climbFudge)
	--	RightHip:SetDesiredAngle(-desiredAngle)
	--	LeftHip:SetDesiredAngle(-desiredAngle)
	--end

	-- Tool Animation handling
	local tool = getTool()
	if tool and tool:FindFirstChild("Handle") then
	
		local animStringValueObject = getToolAnim(tool)

		if animStringValueObject then
			toolAnim = animStringValueObject.Value
			-- message recieved, delete StringValue
			animStringValueObject.Parent = nil
			toolAnimTime = time + .3
		end

		if time > toolAnimTime then
			toolAnimTime = 0
			toolAnim = "None"
		end

		animateTool()		
	else
		stopToolAnimations()
		toolAnim = "None"
		toolAnimInstance = nil
		toolAnimTime = 0
	end
end

-- connect events
Humanoid.Died:connect(onDied)
Humanoid.Running:connect(onRunning)
Humanoid.Jumping:connect(onJumping)
Humanoid.Climbing:connect(onClimbing)
Humanoid.GettingUp:connect(onGettingUp)
Humanoid.FreeFalling:connect(onFreeFall)
Humanoid.FallingDown:connect(onFallingDown)
Humanoid.Seated:connect(onSeated)
Humanoid.PlatformStanding:connect(onPlatformStanding)
Humanoid.Swimming:connect(onSwimming)

-- setup emote chat hook
game:GetService("Players").LocalPlayer.Chatted:connect(function(msg)
	local emote = ""
	if msg == "/e dance" then
		emote = dances[math.random(1, #dances)]
	elseif (string.sub(msg, 1, 3) == "/e ") then
		emote = string.sub(msg, 4)
	elseif (string.sub(msg, 1, 7) == "/emote ") then
		emote = string.sub(msg, 8)
	end
	
	if (pose == "Standing" and emoteNames[emote] ~= nil) then
		playAnimation(emote, 0.1, Humanoid)
	end

end)


-- main program

-- initialize to idle
playAnimation("idle", 0.1, Humanoid)
pose = "Standing"

while Figure.Parent ~= nil do
	local _, time = wait(0.1)
	move(time)
end