Changing a concept in your game mid development

I’m in the middle of development of a game I’m working on. All of a sudden, I’m sitting outside and I get this idea for my game. Unfortunately it would mean I’d have to rework somethings in game which could take some time away from the main development.

The more I think about the idea the more I want to do it. But I hate the fact that I put a lot of effort and time into something that I’m going to replace with this idea.

My question is how often does this happen to you? Do you do it anyways? Does it take a lot of time to implement the change?

If this is in the wrong sub, please tell me where to move this, thank you!

5 Likes

Here is my opinion on what to do
You should do both not one of them I know this is gonna take some time but atleast you are satisfied with doing both things not putting alot of effort starting over maybe the game your working on could be the successful game you don’t know you are becoming better at development anyways
OR
Keep the scripts and all the things you made for later maybe to use it in another game and complete the game later and focus on your new idea

By the way This didn’t happen to me before happened to me in early development not mid so I don’t exactly know what to do but that’s what I would do

2 Likes

Good rule of thumb; if you think it will significantly improve your game, do it.

There have been many instances of games changing plans mid-development, and they turned out great because of it.

For example, the hit 2008 Rockstar Game, Grand Theft Auto IV was supposed to have a much bigger map, featuring a Long Island and Upstate NY. However halfway through development, they decided to scrap it, and focus on a smaller, more detailed map instead.

Grand Theft Auto V also had much more vegetation, until they realized it would be a performance issue, resulting in them removing a VAST amount of vegetation.

I’d say it’s a good thing you’re not almost done with development, since that would add much more workload onto you.

2 Likes

Happened before, lots of times.

Originally it was a round-based team game. Then it became an open-world RPG shooter. Now it’s a survival game. That’s not including the more specific changes such as the movement or combat system.

Just implement the change if you want it. It’s normal for ideas to change or get better as you progress. It’s not an obstacle.

2 Likes

I think you should mostly always change your game to be the best it can be; So long as you aren’t reworking everything about the game, it shouldn’t be fine. Your main concern should be time, really, and if you’re doing devwork as a hobby then you don’t need to worry.

As a side-note, this is why modularity is so important - Making sure everything is modular means you can swap out and change things in your game without breaking everything else!

This happens to me a lot, and I generally make the change - I’ve reworked dialogue in my games countless times, as an example, but since my dialogue system works fully “out-of-the-box”, I can just add/remove/change lines and be fine.

I do understand your frustration though! It sucks that you have to redo everything you already put effort into, but you also have to keep in mind that without the initial effort, your new game would have never been seen in the first place. Your time wasn’t wasted to any degree - That time is just not seen by the player, and that happens a lot with iterative development like playtesting games.

Good luck!! I promise it’s worth it lol