I have not played the majority of these games in a very long time (i would have last played death penalty in sometime around november?) and certainly not before many others later in the list. In a private browser window (no extensions) this is still happening.
Hi @pyxfluff, the Continue sort is intended to be partially-chronological, i.e. things you’ve played more recently are chronological, and the rest is reranked. A fully chronological version of this sort can be found in “Recently Visited” (click on the search bar to see it)
The team has been testing increasing the number of experiences in your Continue sort, which is why it is feeling more random right now. We are continuing to iterate to strike a balance between serving more relevant experiences that you’ve enjoyed before and not freaking users out.
I will close this ticket in a couple of days since it’s technically not a bug, but your feedback has been forwarded to the team. Thanks for reporting!
tldr: not-fully chronological is expected behaviour, but you’re right that it has been “worse” recently and we’re continuing to test improvements