Dandys World FPS Fangame Feedback

A PvE Kill-them-all shooter fangame of dandys world.
Game : Gardenview Disaster (ALPHA) - Roblox
NOTE : Game take quite a long time to load in so please wait.

I’ve been working on my fangame for a while now. And i can’t really find anyone to criticise or playtest the game to truly know any of the flaws , Since nobody play them. So i need some feedback from you guys.

Feedback Questions

  1. Is the game too hard for you?
  2. Are UIs confusing for you?

Additional Questions

  1. Is this copyright infringement? Am i wrong for making this?
  2. Why this game doesn’t get player at all? I didn’t market it , is that the primary reason?
2 Likes

The game looks nice. Don’t know about copyright, but alot of devs are happy with fan made content. I did find most levels quite difficult as the npcs were too fast to escape easily. A couple of weapons also failed to function.

1 Like

Wait which weapon didn’t work?

I swear it work fine for me every time.

The game is okay, to answer your questions:

The game is pretty normal-difficulty on my opinion, BUT the game could be confusing for an average player. I myself doesn’t play dandy’s world and I got confused on what my goal should be at the start, I am just blindly shooting anything that I could kill.

UI is pretty good simple yet effective.

I’m not sure about copyright though. it’s a fan-made game as long as u get permission from the owner/creator to publicly publish it and you clearly stated that it is fan-made, I think you’re all good.

And here’s the thing why it does not get players:
1 - You need to atleast somewhat post online, or into some online platforms about your game to get recognition. There’s a thing that talks about the algorithm somewhere here in devforum.?
2 - Maybe because players that plays the original dandy’s world is usually a kid or in mobile, so they don’t just find these types of games enjoyable… I see that you’ve taken inspirations to some other similar genre

that’s all, just gave my quick thoughts!

1 Like

Thank for your feedback!
I will try to fix those issue you mentioned.

1 Like

pretty responsive and rlly good, it’s rlly like decaying winter and cry of fear which is cool, finding PVE games nowadays are pretty rare here, it gets the job done but 2 things that i think would need a fix is how the bullets interact with the world here, killing toons while they’re in other rooms wouldn’t go through until im inside the room they’re currently in

shoving on other hands, they dont rlly do anything even when getting close

1 Like

Thank for the feedback!

Unlike shoving in Decaying Winter , How it work in this game is opposite , It only work on enemy that are about to grapple you

It did NOT end well…

Thanks everyone for feedback again though!

1 Like

oof… I didnt know you were on devforum too, sorry about that :sob:

2 Likes

How did you find me??
well it a month ago now. time to move on

2 Likes

I always have creations feedback channel notifications enabled, ig I missed this post two months ago

1 Like