AI can not make this quality of water visuals as it is my own creation, it does not understand layering, Roblox Studio Techs and anything besides anything mid, if you take a look at AI games you will know how good it is at map building and much more. The water is not hard to do as well, mesh API, wave math functions that you can find online so easily and just enough of CS & Roblox Building you can do this water stylized look in 2-3 hours. AI is the showcase video and the images. It can not create a simple move from a boat, let alone a whole system. If you do not know how the work is done, AI can not come even close. Try to do something with it and you will see that it really can not. Using AI is not that deep, I do not know why some-people make a big deal, if the end result is safe, secured and it does what it is needed, there is no need to go melodramatic.
" Approximately 84% to 92% of developers use AI tools in their work or personal projects, according to recent industry surveys" --GOOGLE
" 44% of the top 1,000 Roblox creators use official or third-party AI tools" - Google â
So using AI for work for me is really normal, all companies that I have worked for, in systems or web development eager to use AI to be productive and overall better results.
Did you not understand the point of my message? Why do you have to spit out a barely readable word salad for feedback you supposedly dictate as not being feedback?
Get a grip, dude, you are the worst type of AI supporters as all you care about is the product, never the trust, never the wasted material and stolen data, noo, just always the result.
Let me know if I can be more clear or is any concept or word that you did not understand. Thank you for the feedback, here to get better : D.
Everyone cares about the product that is what it is delivered. What do you mean by trust and wasted material and stolen data? You need to do more research on the field, let me know if you need any help. Can u elaborate?
AI generated marketing, AI generated post, likely AI generated resource, untrustworthy poster who takes offense to feedback, yeah no never trying this.
It is unfortuantely that deep.
All people like you do is care about the final result and never anything else. Everything else matters as much as the final result, unfortunately.
And even then, your final result looks insanely low quality because youâve used AI for everything to promote it.
Literally no feedback was given from anyone. I`ve contacted the people who have bought it and they are not reporting any issues so I would say the work is pretty solid and one of a kind. Feel free to make a better one if you can.
I am working on showcases and an experience to truly see the system so look out for that. Keep in mind that you can also add waves that are animated and do not cause lag.
And using AI is not that deep, all industries have made it their standard at this point, feel free to keep up. If the end result does what is needed for, has no issues and has been looked into there is really no need to be this melodramatic over AI.
Literally Roblox has their own AI and are trying to promote it nonstop and that is okay. AI is the new reality and if you are okay or not with it, you need to keep up.
I say people will have negative opinions pretty much on everything, unless they do it so if you happen to buy it, please give feedback not AI opinions. Tell your friends : D
Hiring a human who uses AI is currently the most practical and efficient approach, as pure AI still requires heavy human supervision, while a human alone lacks speed. Also depending on the task the AI can be way more expensive. Just Look online, you will see the mistakes that many companies have made, costing in thousands of USD.
The post is about the water system though, if you think u can do it with AI feel free too, the layering is my own invention and 7 years of experience. Here is what AI created with a md file and many skills and references. Not good at all. AI is bad at 3d workload, I prefer to use it for opinions, experience, feedback, optimization and productivity, not to let it vibe create anything. It uses parts for VFX and does not understand how engines operate. Making it myself is much easier than explaining it, but anyone has their own comfortable work zone, and I am okay with it.
Well, when we can at least tell youâre using AI in what youâre selling, our own opinions on AI are relevant.
I am never going to give money to anyone who uses AI in their product. Youâre using it for marketing, the whole devforum post, all images and the showcase video. Thatâs enough to lose support from myself and anyone like me, which is a lot of people.
With how positively youâre also commenting about AI, itâs also very likely it was used for programming, too. Youâre also trying to undersell what AI is capable of as justification to prove you arenât using it, and itâs really obvious that youâre just lying about AIs capabilities.
Theyâd avoid it as much as I am.
My friends have the same views on AI as me. Why would they choose to support you when you are this openly using it?
If you want to keep getting defensive and bringing up all your pretty crappy arguments, be my guest. Just donât expect people to like you or your product because of it.
You donât deserve support, you donât deserve anything.
Plus, you canât even get your own story straight.
Do not buy it then, that is a you issue. Not begging anyone to. I know what AI is capable of and in 3d workload is not great at all, look at the front games, it does the job so generic and it doesnât use anything how it supposed to.
Yeah I do not use DevForum at all, after everyone like you became a dev, the forum got just a platform to argue and not share ideas or any new things, so I just did commissions, read articles and tried real communication servers rather talking to people like you, there are pretty amazing new and veteran devs here too, but it is like finding a 4-clover. Also to clarify it is 7 years now, going 8(Im 21 not 18 in case that was not clear or you would quote/ss stuff again). DevForum is the most unused platform by me because of the young and larping communitY â not much need for it so yeah.
Talking about AI, because that seems where u need help more and does not seem to quite get at all, good luck saying to it to create this showcase, let alone optimize it create textures and pretty much everything. Saving you time to not look online for anything its my own build and it runs very well in mid end devices ~ 8milion tris. I do use AI for personal work but I know how, when and everything that comes up with it. Yeah, totally. Just like when the pocket calculator came out in the 70s. It completely wiped out all mathematicians overnight and sucked up the entire worldâs solar energy. Truly a dark time for humanity â I totally understand your point. Glad we agreed
nobody was talking to me but 90% of everything uses AI now, so I guess that means you might as well just get off the internet if you donât like AI in anything at all.
How itâs used is important, also me not wanting to monetarily support products which use AI doesnât mean I canât use anything that uses AI.
I play fortnite, I donât buy vbucks or anything, mainly because I have better things to spend money on but also due to fortnites use of AI.
Same thing goes for content on Roblox. I play games which are clearly made with AI to varying degrees (primarily because I donât have any other options at this point), I donât monetarily support those games however.
I am a lot more incentivized to spend money on a product knowing AI wasnât used in its creation. I can still choose to spend money on a product even if it had AI used in its creation at my own discretion of what I consider an overstep in use of AI.
This product here, the person behind it and pretty much everything relating to it is what I consider an overstep, which is why I choose to not support it. From my interaction with OP, they arenât exactly the nicest person to talk to, theyâre very arrogant, egotistical, refusing to listen to feedback, etc. Even ignoring the egregious amount of AI being used in this thread by OP, I still would choose to actively not support him or his product because of how he behaves.
Thereâs a lot that goes into me considering whether something is worth my time or money, itâs not all black and white.
Also, maybe donât quote an AI as a source to how many people use AI. From what Iâve read recently, only around 45-50% of games on Steam use the AI disclosure label to describe how AI was used. Thatâs a lot less than near 85%.
So let me get this straight: You click on my post and trash talk it based on your opinion. An opinion that I do not know who wants it. You have not even tried the plugin at all so I do now know what kind of feedback you are giving by just trash talking with no evidence, just based on personal standards. You do not like AI, sure do not give opinions on stuff about it. Calling me arrogant while you saying I do not deserve support or anything, crappy arguments which are based on facts that you can look up on your own and manipulate people to believe your fake words it is so wild to me, I honestly do not know how.
If you do not like the product do not buy it, but to come here and attack me personally for no reason at all just because of your outdated opinions is wild. Calling me a liar and so many other stuff and never apologizing after I explained everything â It is disrespectful, try to respect more.
If you come at my post, trash talk me and my product based on personal beliefs and manipulating other people that it is true, you right that I will talk back. You need to grow up and try to think more on your own, do not let the ego and pride take over so much.
As I said the plugin was meant to be local, so I have it for my own projects in one click. By perfecting it even more with splashes, moves, foam and interactive features I thought to sell it. It is my own layering system, textures and idea. AI, as I also said but you like to hear your own thoughts rather learn and open your eyes to new ideas, was used for the images and video showcase of the post, that is why it is not good and also as I said again I am working on new showcases and experiences to show it`s potential. I used it also to test, try a way to break the water in anyway and debug the code and give ideas on what to add next. He was the one who told me to make those interactive features and helped how.
I have gotten many ideas and suggestions by the community and I will try to add them soon, bit hard due to Robloxâs restrictions but I am finding ways by experimenting and discussing with AI. With AI because it can research thousands of pages and come back with clean report â something that will take me weeks to do, he does it within a few seconds.
Do not get me wrong either, I do not like when AI is used for 100% of work and in the end is sloppy. But I use AI to be used to be more productive and organized. And again if you do not support AI just leave the 90% or so of developers to do alone, I`m sure you have a lot of stuff to catch on rather to argue with them over 5 bucks.
For what I can tell that is what your whole personality is, you have your own opinions and refuse to believe the reality of facts. Best way for you to grow as a person is to form your opinions and change those opinions based on what you read and find, opinions change with the more you know about a subject, if you do not try to suck new information, your will not grow at all.
Feel free to quote yourself on the feedback you gave about the product, like it does not look good, or you can try this way to make it look better. All I saw was trash talk based on your thoughts and personal attacks about me.
Here is another photo of the water made by plugin. Read the posts more carefully as what you say truly is hurtful. Thank you and waiting for your apologies. Sorry if I made you feel bad or proved you wrong in a mean way in this reply or many others above. Do not take anything personaly <3
Almost all feedback is opinionated. A simple âI donât like X featureâ is an opinion itself.
The only feedback that isnât opinionated is that of facts, such as âI donât like it because X bug makes it unusableâ
Itâs very clear youâre using AI. Your post has AI generated images, the plugin icon is AI generated, simply judging the formatting of the post compared to other AI posts, itâs likely that was generated with AI as well, so Iâd argue itâs pretty reasonable for one to assume the plugin itself was also AI generated, if not entirely at least a little bit.
There is simply a lot of evidence of you already using AI, but as I canât view the source code without purchasing it, thereâs no way I can confirm or deny whether the plugin also uses AI for code.
The simple fact is that youâve already used generative AI a lot, and even if it wasnât used for programming, that use of gen-AI is enough to erode trust in potential customers.
Exactly what Iâm doing.
Iâm saying I choose not to support you or your product because you use Gen-AI and youâre being childish over what Iâm saying. Plus, fun fact for you, most people donât like AI. Just because all the big companies use it doesnât mean people like it. Most of Australia doesnât like AI as a whole, not just gen-AI.
Itâs actually a pretty up-to-date opinion to, as a comsumer, dislike AI. You are the one with an outdated, or at least disillusioned opinion.
Plus, youâre the one keeping this going. Iâd be very glad to stop replying if you do as well, but Iâll keep going as long as you are.
Itâs not manipulation if evidence for my claims is easily visible. Yknow, water found in ocean. Itâs not hard to see youâre using Gen-AI for this.
I never one said you did use it for code, just that you could have and that itâs a safe assumption that you could have based on your use of AI elsewhere.
If youâre going to insult me more than Iâve insulted your use of AI, I think youâre the one who needs to grow up.
Imagine getting upset because someone said that something you didnât make is bad.
I think you need to take that to heart yourself.
Iâm not gonna lie I got hella ego, but at least I donât get mad when someone tells me AI is bad.
Thatâs one of the good use cases for AI. Itâs really good for data analysis.
Iâm entirely against the use of Generative AI in paid products, which is exactly what youâre doing by using it for the images and whatnot. Again, I canât definitively say whether AI was used to generate code as well, although there is a basis for assumption already in place due to AI blatantly being used elsewhere.
I got things I could be doing, but this is just a fun past time for me to do in my free time, and trust me, I have a lot of free time.
I have opinions and care about facts. Fact is, youâre using Generative AI in a paid product, which goes against my own opinions for how AI should be used.
Fact is, most people in Australia do not like AI and think it should be regulated a lot more, weâve banned AI data centers being built in remotely urban areas, etc.
Fact is, the general population of the world doesnât like AI. And of course, we canât avoid it if everything is AI. You see a million people playing AI generated games on roblox because itâs all thatâs being made now, itâs all thatâs being pushed by the algorithm.
You see people using AI assistants such as Gemini on their phones more because all the alternative options were removed.
Itâs almost like if you force something into everything and remove all the alternatives, everyoneâs going to use it despite of their opinions on it because they donât have other options.
Already do that every day.
The difference between you and I is I donât go reading the business articles co-authored by Sam Altman which lie about AI and how itâs the second coming of Christ, instead I read real reports of how real every day people perceive AI, and I factor in how I perceive AI.
Slight politics warning
I also donât have a government which is as pro-AI as Americas government. Like, yes they are allowing data centers and whatnot but at least we arenât calling it âsuper intelligenceâ and have our PM posting AI slop.
Iâve been reading a lot on AI, thatâs the entire reason I have my opinions on it. Iâve seen how itâs been resulting in people losing their jobs, making things infinitely worse, the amount of spending going into it, the bubble it is, you have Sam Altman saying people shouldnât have RAM in their personal computers, etc.
Youâre talking like Iâm just following what everyone else is doing. My opinions line up with a lot of other peopleâs because thatâs the general consensus on AI.
Game development is a form of art, and AI should have no place in art. And at the very least, youâre using it in a much worse place, literal art.
Just because something is capable of doing something doesnât mean you should use it for that. Thatâs a very common thing you can say about AI.
Yes, you can use AI to replace moderators and pay less, but then moderation becomes significantly worse.
You can use AI to generate images, but itâll look like shit, itâll look AI generated.
You can use it to be lazy and do a school work for you, although you shouldnât do that. You wonât be learning anything and youâll struggle later in life because of it.
Iâm personally of the belief that it should be illegal globally to sell anything that had generative AI used in itâs creation with AI content remaining in the final product. As much as I personally would prefer proper temporary assets, I can understand using AI as a template for you to then replace eventually. I would be lying if I said I hadnât used AI for a temporary asset which I then went back and made from scratch with the AI as the basis for design.
If you wanted me to say anything, Iâd say the examples youâve provided just donât fit in roblox because roblox lacks the lighting engine required to make the water visually line up with everything else. The water system would look infinitely better with global cel shading, but roblox doesnât offer cel shading as an option.
And again, just your use of Generative AI on the product page is bad to me personally. Some people are gonna be fine with it, to me though it just makes it look low quality and like not much care was put into one of the most important parts of it. Almost like all you care about is the final result and not at all what goes into getting there.
Reading the replies here, too many cavemen. OP, ignore those AI haters (cavemen), they just cannot use AI correctly. As long as your resource performs better and you know exactly what you are doing then that what matters just disclose properly the usage of AI (if you use one to help you developing the system). They are just upset, cannot accept their ego being crushed.
In reality, companies now even track the usage of tokens to check whether the developer is working or not. If you cant adapt to the rapid changes in tech then better find another career because whether you accept it or not, AI usage skills is a very trend topic and is now being considered as basic skills a developer should put on their portfolio.
I asked if people have an opinion on the plugin, this can be done better this way, i found a glitch, I saw this feature on the video how does it work, you can add this. This is what feedback is, feedback is not coming at me and attacking me personally. Saying that I should not deserve anything because I use AI for help is wild to me.
Good then do not make it a clear way that AI was used. The way you describe that I am using AI you make it look like the whole person you are talking behind the screen (me) is fully AI. I have said multiple times what is AI and what is not on my post. Feel free to read it again or ask questions if not clear.
So then do another thing do not trash talk people if you do not like what they do. Simply just ignore. Creating images just headers and icon with AI, is really not that deep. I wrote a prompt, the generated image was good enough so yeah. Feel free to make some headers on your own or hire someone, ill credit you in the post when I use them.
People do like AI, depends what it is used for. For those brainrot videos, games fully with AI, that no system works, models with abstracted normals and so many more I do not. But for as a helper/assistant that does the job in 3 seconds when you need more than 1 day, is good. But you do what you do, do not attack people if they do what you do not. Companies and many people use AI.
Then I suggest you become an AI user, as other wise you will talk a lot. I will not leave stuff unanswered as this is my post + I get this more pushed to people, so you are doing me a solid. <3
You did say that with the post being AI the whole resource is AI.
Oh sorry if it was an insult to you. I meant to grow up as a person with opinions, like to have opinions change depending on what you learn and reason with. I am not upset, upsetting is that there are âDevsâ like you, that do not know how the industries work and yet form and give opinions â based on personal preference rather facts and needs.
What you said was calling me words and making me and product look bad just based on your opinions. It is different when you say what you think and make others believe what you think. I am just trying to give you the truth that has been going since 2020, if you can not accept it. Be done at that. The plugin water system, in case you forgot what this post was about, not AI and your personal beliefs for AI.
Then what makes you the right to insult people. Literally I have told you around 2-3 times the use of AI in this plugin. And you still going at it. Seems like you want to just argue, do not you have something else to do?
I can tell, arguing with 90% of the devs must need a lot of free unpaid time for you. Glad you like what you do.
Great let`s keep âmy own opinionsâ out of this post for future references here. The post is about the plugin, none of your AI opinions. You are pushing this too much and afraid your account might have consequences.
I looked it up and it says that there are discussions about it, like to ban them near residencias areas, not to fully ban AI at all. Surveys also show that around 60% of people use AI, like simple everyday not for work. Did not look at that. Please be more correct on your findings, these are bland lies. Before you look at the image below, AI does not create stuff out of nothing, it reads and reports back on the references (For this case was 7News Australia)
Feel free to read a whole 50 page article if you like. No one stops you, as time goes by stuff will be more automated. I build DevOps systems for companies and a job that needed 5 people and days now takes 3-5 people and hours. If you not like AI at all, as someone said do not use the internet at all at this point.
This section is out of the blue but sure.
You do not change opinions at all. I said what is AI and what is not on my product and post and you still do not say sorry or edit the post so people do not get misinformed. The difference of you and me (grammar wrong at your end but it is okay) is that I do not know what you just said even is, but you sure have read a lot of this Sam A. that you clearly do not like.
As you stalked my profile sometime ago, I am not from USA. So i do not know what or who you are trying to insult or say.
The whole thing is all Roblox btw in my screen shots provided. All you need is one mesh shape and in one click you have the water. We devs, becuse of Robloxâs limits and requirements, try our best to achieve what is needed by workarounds. Same I did with this plugin, this is why AI can not do this system.
AI uses parts instead of VFX and beams and so many other mistakes that you got no idea.
Stylized water from my plugin also has options for you to change the layers IDs, meaning you can keep the water system and change itâs texture, making it lowpoly, realistic, your gameâs style or any style you want. You just need an ID to replace. Will do more presets in the future for the style so you can easily click to change the style of the water.
Well yeah, I am selling the product not the way it was made. The product looks good, it is my own idea/creation, safe, not broken or glitchy, no lag, layering is my own too, IDs are mine.
You did say before good use of AI to make a 1 week work turn into 5 minutes, that is why the AI was used for the plugin. For the post images, I would have not hired an artist anyways. The headers background, the boat has 2 moves behind it, like what in the world makes you think that AI will replace real jobs. Repetitive and non human based jobs surely. But for art, if a company does that it will fumble within 2 months.
You are welcomed to read post #39 and it is fully true. All companies i work and have worked with urge AI, my friends who have real jobs by the way and not a lot of free time also agree to this. Thanks yawnTooMuch.