Hello all,
i am DescendentsDev i mainly script but today i decided to use paint.net and design a game icon so i was wondering if i can get feeback on it:
btw i cant update it through blender with roblox exporting because of this:
Also when im designing and i add something new to it it doesnt let me copy it to the main picture
I don’t know what to say, this doesn’t look like you put some effort into it and just slapped those images and added text on a background…
It seems a bit basic, and not very interesting to look at. Along with this, simulator is spelled wrong. Your person isn’t properly inserted in, as you have parts of the legs and arms erased and lots of white areas. Try making your icon more interesting by showing some of the fun things players can do in game, and make sure the photos look neat, not half erased. If this sounds like a challenge, try hiring either a gfx designer or a gui designer to make the icon for you.
Well the icon needs to be more creative
You can make a screenshot and put it on the background
Where’s the flavor!? like i understand that your a beginner but please add some effort. 
Working rn imma try to add flavor to it
It seems like you didn’t put any effort into it. Try to spice it up a bit with a few effects! Also the text is very non-fitting, I recommend going to a font website to find cool fonts!
Overall, okay thumbnail, and I get your a beginner, but just a little bit more details would make a great difference.
The icon is a great attempt! But I’d like you to put more effort into cutting out the character and onto the background. I would also try to go for a background that has decoration rather than a single color. And I would also try to make the text more noticable and eye catching. But, I still think this is a great attempt!
i think it was a horrible attempt because 1 it was 10 PM 2 it took 5 minutes to make and it was a peice of no effort but we all have opinions
super plain, basic… not really that good, it’s really empty… you just slapped a icon of a player and then you were done.
try to add more to the game icon…
and i’m not sure what happened to the user icon when you tried to remove the grid thing that was around the player icon possibly? just use like, some sort of magic tool and lower it’s tolerance so that it can only get like the grid thing, don’t know how to call it.
I’m not saying you didn’t put your heart into it but it doesn’t look like anyone would pay attention to it… If you can try hiring someone to do it for you since 3d icons are mostly what everyone is using right now. To be completely honest I don’t know if I would ever play a game with this icon.
First of all, at least pose the character a bit, second you cant export it to blender because you are playing the game, basically insert a character into roblox and then export it, also I think an icon is the thing that attracts people into the game, so try to atleast hire someone to do your icons and thumbnails as its the one thing to attract player, but you can always learn yourself.
I’d would use a 3D software such as blender to render the avatar, have you attempted to redo your game icon, since not much effort has been put into this. It doesn’t feel much has been done that being said not much feedback can be provided on something with not much done to it.
The font doesn’t fit the scheme, it could use some improvements try moving your text ‘Fighting Simulator’ more in the center.
A game icon should show players what the game is about, etc. I highly recommend fixing the icon or even redo it to improve your skills as it take practice and patients to produce a more quality version design. Just to note: try to develop more time into your creation before requesting constructive feedback/criticism.
tryed many times but i made it look worse
Open PDN > Blue background > copied avatar shot > pasted into canvas > Used magic wand & failed, > Calibri text + green color > different font + different text
