Feedback on a game!

Help and Feedback Creations Feedback
1

I have been working with another developer on a Tower-Defence game and we would like feedback!
Keep in mind the following things:

1. The only map that works is, “Forest/Dessert,” Map
2. We only have 20 waves
3. We are still working on making more of the maps work
4. There are expected some bugs (if there are, please tell us)
5. We are going to add more characters

All of that aside, here is the game:
❄ CHRISTMAS ⛄ Mage Defenders - Roblox.

If there is anything that we might need to add, just tell us!

6 Likes
2

Sorry but I couldn’t really play the game because no one was there with me to start the round, maybe add a solo round for testing purposes. The lobby is good but in my opinion, its too small to stay and may feel claustrophobic to some players. Good Luck on the development of this game :slight_smile: .

2 Likes
3

Oh, the maps change, so if you wait, it will have the map!

1 Like
4

Really good game! Very high potential, I really liked the little cutscenes when the bosses showed up, most TD games forget how much they matter. A couple of things need some work though:

  • Player to player collisions
  • Make all troops non-collidable, you try use this
  • A bigger lobby
  • Opening one UI should close any other open ones
  • Name tags on the troops, players might get confused which is which
  • A tutorial

But other than that, very good progress right now. Nice job!

2 Likes
5

I have some suggestions :

  • you could reduce the wave timer to like 3-6 seconds instead of 12-15 seconds.
  • you should reduce the sell price of the character.

I also found some bugs :

  • when placing the character, if interferes the player avatar and can move it, maybe turn CanCollide off for character when placing them.
  • If the bose enters and the cutscene triggers when you are placing the character/towers, if doesn’t disable the placement, i mean if should automatically stop the placement system when the cutscene triggers and then start it when the cutscene ends.

Other than that, the game is looking well in its low poly style, you could add some more decorative stuff to the map itself, it would look good.

2 Likes
6

:hammer_and_wrench: Thank you for the feedback

1 Like
7

:heavy_check_mark: Thank you for the feedback, I will make sure to note it!

1 Like
8

Any other feedback that anyone can think of, just comment it below!

9

A decently made tower defence game. I have a few critiques and suggestions however.

  • After the start timer in the lobby counted down to 0, it started at 10 again. It should stop counting when the teleport is about to happen unless another player steps on the plate to start their own game.
  • Make the towers uncollidable. Since @MasterRoyale03 and @Darobbap already mentioned this, I will not go into detail about it.
  • There are many tower defence games that follow a similar progression to this one, such as Tower Battles, Tower Defence Simulator and Tower Heroes. I suggest considering what will make your game unique and attempting to make it stand out a bit more from the many games before it.
  • Each tower has a placing limit of 2, at least when you begin the game. With upgrades locked or otherwise unavailable, this makes it very hard to strategize and places more emphasis on progression than careful thinking. Taking inspiration from the Bloons Tower Defence series, I suggest that you increase or remove the tower limit (with compensatory balancing), diversify the upgrades and add more than one tower in a particular price range. The game can still have progression, but I feel it interferes with gameplay too much right now.

A lot of my more in-depth suggestions may be a critique of modern Roblox tower defence games in general, but they should at least be considered if you want to make an original, memorable game. Some of this may be a bit harsh, but I want this game to be unique and different from the many existing tower defence games on the website.

1 Like
10

Thank you for the feedback, we will make sure to change things that we need too!

11

I have some bugs to report:

  • I don’t know if this is supposed to not happen but it didn’t tp me back to the main game at the end of the round
  • Everything is either max level at level one or unavailable to upgrade
  • The placing circle flings you out of the world.

I had genuine fun playing, I suggest you add music and sounds to give the game some soul to it!

1 Like
12

We will make sure to work on that!

Thank you!

1 Like