Feedback on each logo

I started making a lot of logos just recently and they’ve gotten better since then. (I made a really bad logo for Chocoblox Factory Tycoon:

This was when it was called Ghirardelli Factory Tycoon. Literally it was just text with pictures of chocolate lol. FOR THE POLL, DO NOT VOTE BASED ON THIS LOGO ONLY THE LOGOS BELOW.)

So, let’s get started,
Here is one for my game Chocoblox Factory Tycoon:


And another one for a project called Inquisitors. (Basically you are an inquisitor from Star Wars Rebels.)
Inquisitors Icon
And one for another project for my friend called Warships:

How good is each logo? Thanks for replying if you do!

Here is a poll I guess:

  • They are awesome!
  • They are good
  • They aren’t good but aren’t bad
  • They are bad
  • They are the worst logos I have ever seen

0 voters

While I get the look you’re going for here these logos need a bit of work.

Chocoblox’s logo has no contrast between the text and chocolate and is really hard to read. I recommend either changing the color or adding an outline of a different color around the text. The chocolate bar also looks a bit simple.

The inquisitors logo is also a bit hard to read, you could probably fix it by adding a transparent black bag line the “Inquisitors” and in between the red frame, but above the saber.

I like the silhouette of the ship, but all the other parts are off-center, and the grey isn’t well incorporated as a background. I also recommend changing the text color, as brown doesn’t go with the logo as well.

They’re good for beginner logo designs though!

2 Likes

it needs a lot of work i suggest if you want a realistic logo make a render then edit it to your liking it will also bring in more attention to the logo and also detail as these are VERY simple and have no detail at all and will not bring attention to somebody but say this gfx/render i made not long ago at all will bring somebody attention:

So i suggest rendering and editing a logo rather than just editing a logo.

1 Like

I don’t want to make a rendered logo YET.

I might try later, but for now as a beginner I’m starting with just editing pictures.

2 Likes

i understand but the earlier you learn to make a rendered logo the more you will know in the future so always try new things as i always in every gfx i make, i then try different ways to make it so then in the future so say if im making a gfx i always experiment with the ways i can make it like the gfx i made above before editing looked like this:


Which wouldn’t look good with just a random background but before i had experimented with the way i made it so i already knew other ways to make this gfx and this was the one which stood out the most so i went with it. (Sorry if that didn’t make sense i went brain dead half way through)

1 Like

Your logo is pretty cool just need a little more improvements.

Well I’m not that expert enough, but I know some points on designing a logo.

When you make a logo, you must understand the game or group first. For example, Inquisitors was a Sci-fi game, so you must make a logo that has Sci-fi feelings on it so people will know that game was all about Sci-fi. The Inquisitors really matches the theme, the colors and font really match.

For the Warship logo, you need to use another bold font and change the color. It looks a bit odd tbh.

It was a good start for beginner though.

2 Likes

What program do you use to edit your logos? @IAmPinleon

2 Likes

I felt that the Warships logo was not as good as the others.

That’s a great thing to think about when making my next logos :slight_smile:

I downloaded a star wars font and made the Inquisitors like that. The font is the same one used to make the Star Wars logo.

  • Inquisitors’s theme is Sci-fi
  • Chocoblox Factory Tycoon’s theme is cartoony
  • Warships’ theme is unknown, but it is a warships game, duh

@YTGonzo Welcome to the community! I just use the editing software that is on my computer already. I didn’t download it, I just found it lol.

1 Like

I recommend you to use Paint.net (free) for the starter pack and when you take more advance try to use Adobe Photoshop (paid). And for the fonts make sure you use “free for commercial use”.

If you are serious about getting better than you should use Photoshop(a paid option), or “paint.net” (a free option). Both of these programs can give you the tools to create some cool art.

@YTGonzo @TWINGILLS I don’t want to use a different editing software yet.

I’m fine with the one I have currently :slight_smile:

Depends on you pal, keep improving! :smiley:

1 Like

You know, my main job isn’t to make logos/icons. I’m usually a scripter.

I will, I promise :slight_smile:

1 Like

I’m a new member so I can’t show you some of the logos from my game that I made with Photoshop.

1 Like