Hello guys! my, it’s been quite a long time since i’ve posted on here..
anyways, i’m here to ask for feedback on some models i’ve made, i think i’ve made some decent progress since my last posts
Any feedback and/or criticism is greatly appreciated
5 Likes
Awesome swords!
I see the hilts are a bit different, which is good detail.
The top one might be too long imo.
Shade smoothing vs flat is preference, so no big critiques really.
1 Like
thanks for the compliment!
The top one is intentionally long, it’s a Longsword. thanks for the feedback on that though, i might shorten the blade a little bit later!
I usually use AutoSmooth for everything, i can’t stand flat shading imo, hate seeing all the lines and it makes texturing a living NIGHTMARE.
1 Like
Hello. I like the style.
My suggestion (totally not an expert): the longsword hilt should be able to contain booth hands, gripped, maybe it’s a little short?
And, i would add a bit of variance at the pommel, at the end of the hilt. A gem, or a decoration, in some models would be perfect.
Keep it up mate
1 Like
thanks for the compliment!
It may not seem like it, but the longsword hilt can be gripped by both hands.
i’ve been doing weapon modeling for quite some time now, but there’s always a few things that i struggle to model when making weapons, handguards, and pommels.
Sooo.. I usually stick to rounded, spherical pommels, and mostly straight handguards.
I’m actively trying to improve on that though, so maybe soon in my next few posts there will be more swords with more.. different pommels and guards?
Analyzing swords models by @FroggyDevss…
Successfully analyzed by the Real Developers Nation Council Leader
Rating: 9/10
Nothing bad to say about them, they look good, but they are a little similar to each other
Good j*b on these Swords
Thanks!
They are all intentionally similar, i made them as a sort of weapon pack i was planning to sell.
Amazing swords. Some VFX like a spark or shimmer effect would go nicely with them. Keep up the good work.
1 Like
Thanks for the compliment!
I absolutely suck when it comes to making VFX, so i tend not to even try. Besides, it would be a pain to fit that into a static image of a sword, which is what i post in this thread
True lol. Looking forward to seeing anymore swords you make.
Thanks, i’ll be posting more swords soon, just gonna take some time to make them of course.
1 Like
Loooove these. Now I wanna get back into making swords, haven’t modelled once since 2024 
What app do you use to texture them?
1 Like
My bad for the late-ish reply and thanks for the compliment!
I use Substance 3D Painter 2025 by Adobe
1 Like