Feedback on these icons i made for a UI!

Help and Feedback Art Design Support
1

ranks preview pre
ranks preview pre8400×1400 5.25 MB

It’s for an upcoming gunfighting game, not my project but i was commissioned to make ranking icons for them!
Feedback would be really appreciated as this is my 1st UI work since 2016 :smiley:

7 Likes
2

I like the icons in the UI that you made.

1 Like
3

Oh wow nice design! I would just put numbers near the roman numerals or replace them because some younger people may not know about them.

1 Like
4

Those are some nice designs you have on the UI :+1:

1 Like
5

They are looking good so far.
Some feedback:

  • The logo’s are looking very flat. Adding some depth to them will really make them pop out. For example check out the badges they use for the Halo 5 ranks.

  • The use of soft brushes make them look like they have been smudged. Try creating a version of one of the logo’s in a vector format and see how that looks. Experimenting is key!

  • Last but not least when making a logo its important to see what it stands for but having 4 of the same logo for 4 different ranks can be confusing. I really like what you did for the last one of that rank before promotion but it will be much cooler to do that for every division in that rank. Make people proud they have gone from silver 2 to silver 3 by rewarding them with a new logo they can show off!

1 Like
6

I thought about that too! but the customer wanted them roman so I had to make them like that :smiley:

7

Thank you for the feedback I appreciate it!