I needed some thumbnails & icons for my island survival game (check my other post). I created two icons and three thumbnails. I want to hear your opinions on them and which icon for the game you prefer. They’re intended to be saturated and eye catching.
What icon do you like best, A or B?
I understood A better than B but overall I think that the blue sky helps
Icon A looks better but I don’t like how it is just floating next to a tree. As with your thumbnails the first one looks good but the second one the snowman looks odd.
Ha, I get that. It was more just to show a turtle with palm trees to give the idea of an island! 
A looks better because of the bright blue sky in the back.
All of these game thumbnails and game icons look great! Nice job on all of them! All of the thumbnails are good, for the icon though you should use and choose A, the first one since it looks better.
A definitely looks better with a saturated blue sky. When making high CTR icons, you should use bright, vibrant and saturated colors to separate the main elements from the background. The items should be clear and simple. You did that, so well done! ^^
having the icon in a beach/palm biome but having the first thumbnail in a snow biome would be confusing. try to showcase every biome in individual thumbnails, starting with whatever biome is on the icon
