Hello! I have been working on a simulator / RPG type game (Melee Masters) and released it a few weeks ago.
I’m hoping to receive some feedback and suggestions for improving my game icons in order to increase their CTR.
The first / left icon seems to have acquired a higher CTR than the second which seemed surprising to me. I would have thought the flashier, brighter icon would have had more success. Any ideas to why this might be?
Thanks for reading.
The text that’s says melee masters is big enough but if you just going to have armor right above it try making it bigger.
The fonts are readable. Its not to cluttered. I really like it.
My only recommendations are:
-Make the master melees part bigger
-Move pets and new text down so that you can see the tips of the swords
Try that and give it a look
Try making the text bigger and keep either the “pets” text or “new” text.
Maybe the left got more clicks because the black pops out more? The ads look great though!
There’s more contrast on the left one so it stands out more to the eye, the right one is almost all yellow and red, and everything just blends together. With all the different eye-catching icons on roblox, an icon like the right will just get lost in the crowd. The left one is also less visually crowded, a bit easier on the eyes, while still keeping to a color scheme.
The first image is using a Humanoid, which players often like seeing what they would actually be inside the game. (What their avatar could look like.) The second one also is less detailed, mostly because it’s just a gfx, with some text and colors. The first one, however, is a high detail gfx, which will bring in more people. Usually, when a game has high detail gfx images on the icon, it brings in more players.
Take this as an example:
High detail gfx!
Now take this as an example:
You would be less likely to click on it because it’s a lower quality gfx.
Now at the end of the day, both your gfx’s are good, however, what I am showing above is an example of what I mean, the higher quality, more Humanoid-esk character gfx’s and what a player could look like in the game will bring in more attention!
