Game with consistent CCU + good stats but horrendous QPTR

Heyo! I’m Lucille and I made the following game: Deep Blue [ALPHA⚓] - Roblox

The stats are all yellow/top yellow and stuff but the QPTR is SUPER SUPER LOW ~0.62% and the 28th percentile (GG :skull:). The thumbnails are NOT AI.

Impressions:

QPTR:

My QPTR has not managed to go up once during the time I’ve been monitoring it and I’m kinda dumbfounded on what could be the issue. I asked a couple people and have “some” idea on what the problem might be. In my acquisition tab (I know it’s /user not /impression) my Users Impression CTR is 16.32% for home recommendations which means a lot players are clicking on the thumbnail (I think) but my Users Detail Page CTR is only 41%. I not sure but I think this means I have a clicky thumbnail, but very low conversion/people are turned off from the detail page and decide against playing it? What should I do? I feel like the QPTR is holding my game back from reaching higher CCUs…

2 Likes

UNPOPULAR OPNION: try uisng multiple different AI thumbnails. they may actually do better. I found various ai thumbnails got up to 4% QPTR across various different games.

1 Like

I’m not too sure AI thumbnails would do any better as I figure they work best on a much younger audience who doesn’t care. My audience for the game is typically older (13+ to 17+) and wouldn’t really appreciate an AI thumbnail.

4 Likes

I’m just wondering, did you advertise and if you did how much did you put into it over how long? I’m planning on advertising my upcoming game, but don’t know if around 13,000 is enough.

Since you’re probably not going to read the rest, I’ll give one of the more important tips here. I noticed that by your stats, the thumbnail with the boat and lightpost (or whatever the name is), has the highest QPTR, and for good reason since I legitimately think it was a really good thumbnail showcasing your game. On the flipside, one or two of your other thumbnails are almost completely black, so I’d recommend removing those ones if you wanted to see your play through rate increase.

My Theory

I checked your thumbnails out and I think the biggest problem is that it’s hard to depict what your game is about quickly. In fact, I think the combination of name (“Deep Blue”) and your thumbnails force the player to take longer to analyze the game (even for older players).

Anyways, I think the easiest way to fix this would just be adding a main subject/target to your thumbnail so that players could just grasp the meaning quickly.

Here’s an example of what I did for my game:


Obviously considering your game design and aesthetic, you probably shouldn’t make everything so saturated and overly shiny like I did, but the main point is that you want to showcase the main attraction of your game clearly.

Since your game is about exploring the seas, I’d recommend that around 60% of the screen is taken up by a boat in the center, and you can even have an arrow pointing to it.

2 Likes

I did advertise it but mainly for analytics. ~6k over the course of 3 days, then improve on it. During this period, all stats were read (as expected) then after 2-3 weeks, the game magically started getting picked up.

Thanks for the advice, I’ll make sure I take it into consideration!

The game itself is kind of “complex” to explain to new players, but the core is ocean + exploration + friends. Maybe I’ll try to tell a story through the thumbnail that way? The thumbnail with the current highest QPTR sort of follows this format which might explain why it’s the highest.

Interesting, last question is did you do it over the weekend or weekdays? I once spent 15k on ads for 3 days and got 4,000 visits, stats were all green and very very good, yet the game flopped even though it was pretty high quality. I am debating wether to do 12k over the course of 6 days, or 6k over 3 days and another 6k over 3 days.

Ngl I just did it randomly on a summer Monday afternoon, I would think weekends are better but more competition cause everything is thinking the same. My CPP was really bad ~0.2.

try doing 1 to 2 weeks 16 ad credit next time