Have I done this right (character selection)?

hhhiii i am working on a little silly survival game, and i was wondering if i was doing the character selection right.

This is the server module that stores the GAMEPLAY data.

-- // SERVICES
local ReplicatedStorage = game:GetService("ReplicatedStorage")
local CollectionService = game:GetService("CollectionService")
local ServerStorage = game:GetService("ServerStorage")

-- // DEPENDENCIES
local assets = ServerStorage.Assets
local tools = assets.Tools
local spawns = workspace.Spawns:GetChildren()

local RemoteEvents = ReplicatedStorage.RemoteEvents
local RemoteFunctions = ReplicatedStorage.RemoteFunctions
local ReplicatedModules = ReplicatedStorage.Modules
local mod1 = ReplicatedModules.CharacterDetails
local mod2 = script.Parent.BadgeGiver
local CharacterDetails = require(mod1)
local BadgeModule = require(mod2)

local SelectionEvent = RemoteEvents:WaitForChild("Selection", 7)
local RetrieveInfo = RemoteFunctions:WaitForChild("RetrieveCharInfo", 7)

local CharacterManager = {}

function CharacterManager:Initialize()
	print("Initialized - Character!")
end

-- // Documentation or whatever
--[[
MaxHealth - The maximum amount of health the character can have.
MaxSanity - The maximum amount of sanity the character can have.
WalkSpeed - The character's walking speed.
SprintSpeed - The character's speed while sprinting.
DamageResistance - Damage multiplier.
HungerDecay - How fast the player goes hungry (per interval)
ThirstDecay - How fast the player goes thirsty (per interval)
HungerInterval - How often the player's hunger ticks down.
ThirstInterval - How often the player's thirst ticks down.

Tags - A list of tags to apply to the character.
StartingTools - A list of tool names to give the player when they spawn.
]]

CharacterManager.Characters = {
	["Test"] = {
		MaxHealth = 100,
		MaxSanity = 100,
		WalkSpeed = 16,
		SprintSpeed = 21,
		HungerDecay = 0.75,
		ThirstDecay = 1,
		HungerInterval = 7,
		ThirstInterval = 5,
		DamageResistance = 1,
		Tags = {"test_tag_hiii"},
		StartingTools = {"LinkedSword"},
		OnSpawn = function(player, character)
			
		end,
		Requirement = function(player)
			return true
		end,
	},
	["LawEnforcement"] = {
		MaxHealth = 100,
		MaxSanity = 100,
		WalkSpeed = 16,
		SprintSpeed = 22,
		HungerDecay = 0.75,
		ThirstDecay = 1,
		HungerInterval = 7,
		ThirstInterval = 5,
		DamageResistance = 1,
		Tags = {},
		StartingTools = {},
		OnSpawn = function(player, character)

		end,
		Requirement = function(player)
			local badgeID = 807362863281712
			if not BadgeModule:UserHasBadge(player, badgeID) then
				return false, "\""..BadgeModule:GetBadgeName(badgeID).."\" Badge"
			end
			
			return true, nil
		end,
	},
}

CharacterManager.CharacterKeysCache = {}

local function TPPlayer(player: Player, character: Model)
	if #spawns == 0 then
		warn("No spawns found!")
		return
	end
	
	local chosenSpawn = player:GetAttribute("Spawn")
	local target = spawns[chosenSpawn]
	if not target then
		target = spawns[math.random(1, #spawns)]
	end
	character:MoveTo(target.Position)
end

local function InitializeHumanoid(humanoid: Humanoid, characterData)
	if not humanoid then return end
	
	humanoid.WalkSpeed = characterData.WalkSpeed
	humanoid.MaxHealth = characterData.MaxHealth
	humanoid.Health = humanoid.MaxHealth
	for dataVar, value in pairs(characterData) do
		if typeof(value) ~= "table" then
			humanoid:SetAttribute(dataVar, value)
		end
	end
end

local function ApplyTags(character, characterData)
	local dataTags = characterData.Tags

	local existingTags = CollectionService:GetTags(character)
	for _, tag in existingTags do
		CollectionService:RemoveTag(character, tag)
	end

	if not dataTags then return end
	for _, tag in dataTags do
		CollectionService:AddTag(character, tag)
	end
end

local function GrantTools(player: Player, characterData)
	local dataTools = characterData.StartingTools
	if not dataTools then return end
	local backpack = player:WaitForChild("Backpack")

	for _, toolName in dataTools do
		if tools:FindFirstChild(toolName) then
			local tool = tools[toolName]:Clone()
			tool.Parent = backpack
		end
	end
end

local function GetRandomCharacterKey()
	if #CharacterManager.CharacterKeysCache == 0 then
		for name, _ in pairs(CharacterManager.Characters) do
			table.insert(CharacterManager.CharacterKeysCache, name)
		end
	end

	return CharacterManager.CharacterKeysCache[math.random(1, #CharacterManager.CharacterKeysCache)]
end

function CharacterManager.LoadCharacter(self, player: Player)
	local character = player.Character or player.CharacterAdded:Wait()
	local humanoid = character:FindFirstChild("Humanoid") :: Humanoid
	local chosenChar = player:GetAttribute("Character")
	
	local charKey = (chosenChar and #chosenChar > 0) and chosenChar or GetRandomCharacterKey()
	local targetChar = self.Characters[charKey]

	GrantTools(player, targetChar)
	InitializeHumanoid(humanoid, targetChar)
	ApplyTags(character, targetChar)
	TPPlayer(player, character)
	player:SetAttribute("Character", charKey)
	
	if targetChar.OnSpawn then
		targetChar.OnSpawn(player, character)
	end
end

RetrieveInfo.OnServerInvoke = function(player, name: string)
	if name and not (string.len(name) == 0) then
		local detailsGameplay = CharacterManager.Characters[name]
		local detailsInfo = CharacterDetails[name]
		
		local canUse, reason = detailsGameplay.Requirement(player)
		
		local package = {
			MaxHealth = detailsGameplay.MaxHealth,
			WalkSpeed = detailsGameplay.WalkSpeed,
			SprintSpeed = detailsGameplay.SprintSpeed,
			DamageResistance = detailsGameplay.DamageResistance,
			Title = detailsInfo.Title,
			Details = detailsInfo.Details,
			Icon = detailsInfo.Icon,
			Render = detailsInfo.RenderImage,
			Owns = canUse,
			Reason = reason
		}
		return package
	else
		-- // Return everything
		local detailsInfo = CharacterDetails
		local package = {}
		for name, data in pairs(detailsInfo) do
			local canUse, _ = CharacterManager.Characters[name].Requirement(player)
			package[name] = {
				Title = data.Title,
				Details = data.Details,
				Icon = data.Icon,
				Owns = canUse,
			}
		end
		return package
	end
	
end

return CharacterManager
-- // SERVICES
local ReplicatedStorage = game:GetService("ReplicatedStorage")

-- // TEMPLATES
local CharacterTemplate = script.CharacterTemplate

-- // DEPENDENCIES
local RemoteEvents = ReplicatedStorage.RemoteEvents
local RemoteFunctions = ReplicatedStorage.RemoteFunctions

local SelectionEvent = RemoteEvents:WaitForChild("Selection", 7)
local RetrieveInfo = RemoteFunctions:WaitForChild("RetrieveCharInfo", 7)

-- // UI
local SelectionFrame = script.Parent
local MainGUI = SelectionFrame.Parent
local Menu = MainGUI.Menu
local PlayButton = Menu.ButtonContainer.Play

-- // UI - CHARACTER LIST
local SelectionCharactersList = SelectionFrame.Characters.Content

-- // UI - CHARACTER INFO
local SelectionCharacterDetails = SelectionFrame.Details
local SCDStatsContainer = SelectionCharacterDetails.StatsContainer

local SCD_Health = SCDStatsContainer.Health
local SCD_Speed = SCDStatsContainer.Speed
local SCD_Damage = SCDStatsContainer.Damage
local SCD_Icon = SelectionCharacterDetails.Icon
local SCD_LockedText = SelectionCharacterDetails.LockedIndicator
local SCD_Title = SelectionCharacterDetails.Title
local SCD_Details = SelectionCharacterDetails.Details

local SCD_Select = SelectionCharacterDetails.SelectButton

local function SetDetails(name: string)
	local Info = RetrieveInfo:InvokeServer(name)
	if not Info then return end
	
	-- // STATS
	SCD_Health.Value.Text = Info.MaxHealth
	SCD_Speed.Value.Text = Info.WalkSpeed
	SCD_Damage.Value.Text = Info.DamageResistance
	
	-- // ICON
	SCD_Icon.Image = Info.Icon
	
	-- // TITLE
	SCD_Title.Text = Info.Title
	SCD_Details.Text = Info.Details
	
	-- // LOCKED
	if Info.Owns then
		SCD_LockedText.Visible = false
	else
		SCD_LockedText.Visible = true
		SCD_LockedText.Text = `[ LOCKED - {Info.Reason or "???"} ]`
	end

end

local function Refresh()
	local Results = RetrieveInfo:InvokeServer()
	if not Results then warn("Could not retrieve character datas!") return end
	
	for _, child in SelectionCharactersList:GetChildren() do
		if child:IsA("Frame") then
			child:Destroy()
		end
	end
	
	for name, data in Results do
		print(name, data)
		local Template = CharacterTemplate:Clone()
		Template.Title.Text = data.Title
		Template.Icon.Image = data.Icon
		if data.Owns == false then
			Template.LockedIndicator.Visible = true
		end
		Template.View.Activated:Connect(function()
			SetDetails(name)
		end)
		
		Template.Name = data.Title
		Template.Parent = SelectionCharactersList
	end
end

PlayButton.Activated:Connect(Refresh)

This here is the local script in the UI.
I was wondering if i am doing way too much and this can be all simplified or if im on the right track.


The hierarchy if it matters.

If it works it works but here are few suggestions:
• Initialize does not need to be defined as a method (:)
Knowing the Initialize only prints, and does not actually initialize anything, I suggest removing the function instead, or initializing RemoteEvents inside it.

• Drop the pairs iterator and use next, CharacterManager.Characters, and don’t define value variable (do for name in next, CharacterManager.Characters)
Use dictionary for faster lookup in character caches

• if name and not (string.len(name) == 0) then this is bad since it can cause you string.len(nil)
and aswell avoids the bad practice of using not with == operators, which combines into ~=

if typeof(name) == "string" and string.len(name) ~= 0

If I’ve missed any pairs within your code, make sure to not use it, generalized iterator or next is faster than pairs

does next do the same thing as pairs?

pairs uses next internally, so just use next and avoid extra pairs call

One thing I noticed is that you’re storing all the characters within the script. Functionally, there is nothing wrong with this and it’s probably the best option performance wise, but if the game is gonna have a lot of characters then it would be hard to navigate and tweak things when needed.

so make a separate module, i assume?

A seperate module would work great so long as you dont plan to add hundreds of different characters, you could require it from the module that you’re working and it would essentially behave in the same way

(even in the event of hundreds of different characters, it would still be somewhat manageable, just very annoying)