How can I improve my games retention?

Hello!

aghhhh another td!! (mines actually unique I swear! Enemies are sorted into types w different effects, you can combo your towers and much more) (Battle Cats inspo)
I have been working on my TD game for a while now and recently started ads so I can get data on what to improve. The game had really bad playtime 5-10m which I think also correlated into bad retention.

I recently worked on the tutorial a lot and added some things to the first couple stages to hopefully help.

Other potential issues:
UI (I don’t do UI and don’t have the budget for a full rework)
TD oversaturation (I feel mine is unique enough with its two main features tower combos and enemy types) (If there are better ways I can help show them in the tutorial without being to complicated / overwhelming im open to suggestions!)

Any general feedback would help, this game is a passion project of mine but like yk I also do want other people to experience it!

Here is the games link thank you for reading!

Your game’s page (icon & thumbnail included*) has nothing special about. Most users simply impression it as another open-source Tower defence kit game and click off. This first bottleneck likely filters out your users a lot. While it’s not explicitly tied to bad retention, it’s certainly a shortcoming of your game. (Think games like Grow a Garden that vehemently advertise “GROWS OFFLINE”. Users are then led to believe it is unique from other simulator games-- and click.

5 - 10 minutes retention is not that bad (especially at 10 minutes), but not that great either.

The onboarding is flatteringly excellent. New users are instantly shown the CHOICE of a tutorial with all other UI clutter hidden away. (Track whether they click the tutorial or not!)
The tutorial is also well-made and has no apparent issues. My only suggestion in that aspect would be for more visual indicators. The voice and text are excellent and should be enough, but sometimes that isn’t the case, especially if you seek airtight onboarding.

My last suggestion would to be to go full-send on dopamine rewards. The game’s core is well-made, and there already are some effects, but there’s absolutely room for more. Dopamine hits are what keep players playing, and more importantly, returning. You already have daily rewards, which is excellent.

Have you tried sponsors? Your game only has 4000 visits, and so your sample size of retention would be… insufficient.

You just answered yourself why your retention is low. Players are satisfied with playing tons of other popular TD games, and it will be very hard to get them to you, unless you could modify the core of the game substantially (make it fun in a vastly different way) and market it so well they would be enticed to come to you, but that’s a very hard task to do well.

I might be wrong though, so take it with a grain of salt.

May seem harsh, but I want to help you.