Hey everyone,
I’m building a creature-collecting game where you hatch eggs that range from Common up to Mythic, and I’ve reached the point where audio matters as much as the visuals. A Mythic reveal that sounds like a Common one kills the moment, so I want to get the sound design right before launch instead of patching it later.
I’d love to hear how experienced developers actually handle this.
What I’ve tried so far
- Creator Store licensed libraries (such as ProSoundEffects, APM Music, Roblox’s own UI sounds). The quality is good, but finding the right sound takes hours: search results are flooded with re-uploads ripped from other games, which I don’t want anywhere near my game. Searching with ProSoundEffects’ own category wording (for example “Mammals - Wild” or “Musical - Chimes”) helped a lot.
- APM “song families”. Many APM tracks come as Hit, Tag, Sting, Link, 15 s and 30 s cuts of the same piece, which works well for escalation: a short sting for one tier, the full link for a rarer one.
- Free bundles. I looked at the Sonniss GDC bundle, but for my genre it was gigabytes of downloads for a handful of usable sounds.
- Synthesized placeholders. Fine for testing timing, but they sound generic.
What I’d like to learn
- Sources. Where do your best SFX and music come from? Paid packs (which ones were actually worth it?), subscriptions, commissioned sound designers, or your own recordings or synthesis?
- Licensing on Roblox. How do you confirm that a pack’s license allows uploading to Roblox? Do you keep those uploads private to your experience? Are there vendors or license types you avoid?
- Rarity escalation. For tiered rewards (Common → Mythic), do you build one sound family that grows (more layers, longer tails, more low end) or give each tier a distinct sound? How do you keep the top tiers exciting without making everything loud?
- Layering and mixing in-engine. Do you layer sounds at runtime (say, an impact under a choir), duck the music under big moments, or bounce everything in a DAW first? How do you keep loudness consistent across sources (ProSoundEffects next to APM next to custom sounds)?
- Music. Library tracks, commissioned scores, or something else? How do you avoid sounding like every other game using the same library?
- Budget. For a small team, what’s a realistic audio budget, and what would you spend it on first?
My current setup
- Every sound is a slot in one config file (asset id, optional clip region, pitch and volume), so swapping a sound never touches code.
- Rare spawns play layered stings with priorities (a Mythic cuts off a Legendary), and the background music ducks underneath.
- Toasts stay silent when the event behind them already played its own sound, so one event never makes two sounds.
Concrete recommendations would help most: pack names, artists, tools, or a game whose audio you think nails it. Thanks!