How Does This Game Rank When Compared to Competition?

I’ve created an elevator game and it’s no where near the competition. It might be the marketing/branding or the floors might be boring? I’m unsure so I’m looking for feedback from others which is why I came here. Any feedback would be great, be as critical as you want.

My game:
https://www.roblox.com/games/480176514/BIG-Noob-Elevator

Popular competition:
https://www.roblox.com/games/2323391149/The-Elevator-Winter-Update
https://www.roblox.com/games/230362888/The-Normal-Elevator

I know that my game is lacking behind in average visit length, but even if I reached the same average time, my game would be at 50 concurrent while theirs is at > 1000. The issue goes beyond.

2 Likes

From what I’ve gathered, the other games deal with passing the downtime between floors better.

They have things like: Unusual effects on the players, tools they can hold, characters that enter the elevator, constantly changing music, etc.

Try to make things more dynamic.

2 Likes

I don’t really like it theres not a lot of rooms and what rooms there are, theres a couple of rooms of jokes that aren’t really funny and showing them over and over won’t make them any more funny; and the mini games either don’t give you enough time to complete it, or are just boring to play(the obby, no oxygen). It is also very glitchy and after a death i was unable to unequip a skin or use my emotes; and the game gets progressively laggyer the longer you play which might mean a memory leak.

3 Likes

Simple, you made a clone. At best the audience/players will be split amongst the games. No niche.

1 Like

I agree with everything you said. My game is lacking badly.

1 Like

I agree. My game is a good amount of rooms behind. The obby is too generic and the oxygen one is boring. I found out that you’re given too little time in the atlantis map, maze, and smoothie map. Right now there is a bug where you cannot equip skins after dying and it’s a major problem that I plan to fix soon. There might be a memory leak; the game was created a long time ago when I had less experience.

Thank you :smiley:

1 Like