There’s been a discrepancy in select groups’ member counts for a while now. I don’t really have much information on it besides what can be visually seen on the website. Here’s a group that’s known as UCU that is currently affected by this issue. Please send links to your affected groups in the replies so that Roblox staff can look into it!
As shown in the example below: The group displays that it has 4,375 members at the time of this post. But the member count of the “Enthusiast” default group rank alone holds 5,388 users in it, with there being more members within other ranks too. This inaccurately reflects how many members the group has and should be adjusted to do as such.
This issue typically occurs with communities that are “request to join.” When a member is accepted into the group, it does not accurately check the current member count and increases the member role by 2 while increasing the entire group’s count by 1. This has been an ongoing issue that has existed for the past year, but Roblox continues to ignore it because it is considered a visual bug rather than an invalid count of the group’s actual total members.