Ingame Custom UGC pricing should be balanced out

As a UGC creator, while i find the recent feature to be nice the pricing is way too close to items existing on the catalog. Many people outside my field will disagree and don’t know what it’s like to regularly create accessories and I completely expect that since it doesn’t sound great at first but hear me out.

Current Pricing

For reference price floor for hats at least for me is 90 and custom upload fee for ingame ugc is only 105. That’s close enough for there to be pages upon pages of heads and necklaces being uploaded in one day. This isn’t even close to the uploading fee for items either which is 750 robux and typically 1500 to put onsale. If you don’t believe me just go on recently updated on heads + neck and toggle filter to view offsale items. More than 95% of items will be custom ingame items.
It honestly defeats the purpose of creating ugc to resell if people can just customize their own for a super similar price. It was concerning before when pricing was 120 because Thats still a little too close but at least it isnt literally the same price as an accessory with pbr.


Some Item types are already obsolete to resell

Drawn faces, a popular genre of uploading is now obsolete, bling chains have zero purpose of being made + uploaded. other simplistic accessories also have no purpose of recreation to resell. There’s going to later be other accessories that won’t have a purchase of creating to resell once they’re made.

There is a lot of ugc creators that rely on putting items onsale on the catalog as passive income or even full time, those people’s revenues will drastically decrease over a feature like this being out not balanced out correctly.

“The features arent even that good, you can’t go far with it”

Thats because it’s literally been out for less than a week…? Obviously a feature like this that depends on coding will evolve over time and once it does its going to screw up the system. It may not even seem like a big deal currently but it’s better to have it be resolved than wait months later where theres thousands of items customizable and it becoming a more glaring imbalance.

Suggestion

Pricing Wise I’m leaning towards it being only 50 robux more expensive than sellable items type. As in a 100 robux accessory should be 150 to customize your own version

This would not only help existing UGC creators not be screwed over due to the catalog becoming entirely pointless to upload in but It would also benefit the creators that program the features for these items. This would also still be affordable to the general player base due to it being under 200 robux for every accessory type and clothing type.

Agreed, I believe custom upload fee should be higher than the price-floor of accessories on catalog.

Customizable UGC will 100% harm creators’ long-term profits, while clogging even more of the catalogue up. I hope it’s possible to reconsider boosting the pricing on their end.

I agree with this, I also think that the custom UGC items need their own section/area of the catalog so uploading similar items normally won’t be obsolete :pensive_face:

I don’t see the issue with ingame UGC items able to be price the same as a marketplace authored UGC item. Especially if they are very similar assets, such as chains. If a UGC creator makes a similar asset to a customizable version ingame, then it seems like the UGC creator is simply being out competed. The power that a UGC creator has is their ability as an artist to make unique items, and can be made more efficiently than experience that makes similar items programmatically.

I don’t understand the defense of the item reselling system. Users have access to items that they find more personal value in (being customized). Naturally reselling of less personalized items is less important to them. I don’t see anything fundamentally bad about this.

Main issue is the fact those type of games are going to pile up overtime. sure chains are faces are the main two that are obsolete to upload but theres going to be A LOT MORE type of items that would be able to be customized and programmed in features over time.

That’s kind of the point as to why I wrote this lmao. Even more unique type of items are going to eventually end up on the chopping block after the more simplistic items. UGC Creators shouldn’t be penalized over a feature that nobody knew was going to come out. at RDC the preview of the feature was going to just be makeup originally

Adding things or customizing things should always be at least a bit more expensive than the main thing, because its a specialized change for you specifically, thats just how majority of things work :grinning_face:

I agree with this aswell, many ugc creators have to publish for thousands of robux vs this, and still be priced at the same thing.

It’s not a penalty. It’s just the tech is improving and the environment is changing.

The shift doesn’t mean that uniquely authored items will die in favor of simplistic items. Authored items might even become more sought after over procedural items. Similar to the emergence of AI art. If users want tools to find and sort authored items, Roblox will make it.

I also want to show some of my item’s analytics that are clearly affected by the ingame UGC update’s pricing. In my case my most affected types of items is layered clothing; not a specific category but literally everything

This is stats of one of my previous bestsellers. You will see in this graph sales dropped by nearly 40% This timeframe lines up with one of those ingame UGC games added layering to their layered clothing customization game and when this feature became way more known. Which was updated roughly 3 days ago

Incase that Isn’t convincing whatsoever I also have analytics for a layered clothing item that blew up around 1 and a half months ago that has dropped abnormally due to the release of the ingame ugc feature


you see that big dip near the end? Yeah thats ingame ugc’s effect and its going to only get worse

I 100% agree that this is flawed and should be more expensive. Us UGC Creators pay 750 Robux + a publishing advance. As suggested, these in-game items should be, at least, 50 Robux more expensive compared to a catalog purchase.

It is almost as if they are trying to make the catalog obsolete and have complete in-game purchases. For instance, you can easily upload a model in a experience, and just have the players publish that. Not only do you avoid the publishing and publishing advance fee, but you receive 70% of the purchase value (for example for a hat ingame you would receive ~73 Robux, compared to the 27 on the catalog).

That being said, I don’t think your 33% dip is being caused by this update. Your graph indicates drop starting November 11, where the concurrent players for the primary experience, Build a UGC, were only 384 (12th and 13th were 228 and 160 respectively). Unless your items were 1:1 to the ones in-game, and even if they were, I highly doubt this was the root cause of your decrease in sales.

My items affected are mostly from layered clothing, a day prior one of the largest clothing groups launched a UGC creator with layered clothing which has many, many visits due to people promoting it on tiktok. I feel as though it has a lot to do with it even though you may disagree; a drop this sharp isn’t normal when it comes to layered clothing analytics

There are severe limitations to the ability to put high quality textures onto clothing textured in-experience and people can only customize meshes that creators give them access to. The pricing is fine as is.

I do agree that they need to support people who put work into manual creation though, but they should be doing that by severely reducing or entirely removing the upload and marketplace listing fees so that creators can upload way more color/texture variants for their items to compete with in-experince ugc.
In addition also they should reduce the fee to mint Limited UGC copies so that users have more incentive to buy UGC from creators because of the ability to resell (and hopefully in the future trade) the items that they buy.

Stop and let’s not limit accessibility to people who can’t really afford expensive things especially those who are in 3rd world countries

Are you aware of dynamic pricing? Users in 3rd world countries are offered lower pricing on most catalog items.

I am unsure of the relevance of your point.

cough dynamic pricing… they’ll live lmao

idk if it actually boosts sales having it turned on im js worried by turning it off itll affect the algo

Dear ROBLOX, do not increase the uploading price costs. This update alone has gotten more investors to be hyped on Roblox as they can see that there would be more creativity on Roblox. Increasing the price costs would eliminate creativity and most importantly INVESTORS would be LESS INTERESTED because there would be less engagement. Fewer people will be able to upload which means there would be fewer items making investors less interested about the future of Roblox and the stock.

Raising robux costs by a little would actually give them more revenue… its not like im requesting them to spike it up by 1000%; meaning you and many other people would be able to afford making whatever the hell you want, it’s simply to not make other item types on the catalog obsolete. I’m mot sure id you are aware however they also now have decal imports to those games; this means people can rip faces off of other items instead of buying the face themselves? People already have done this before and now UGC face creators have zero purpose of uploading anything because people that cant draw will just rip an image off google or Pinterest and go from there. In other words the “some people can’t draw” excuse does not apply anymore since they will now trace instead.

Another thing, this specific feature isnt what investors want nor is relevant to them. what if i told you, ever since this specific feature came out the stock actually went down? :eyes: Sure a majority of this reason is because of safety concerns since thats what they actually care about instead of creativity however this specific feature has negative influence on stock whether its a small concern or not to investors. Actually let me pull it up what
the stocks look like because you love to talk about stocks and investors so much.
For reference, this feature was not put into any games until the 10th of this month, so the little spike prior to that has absolutely nothing to do with the release of this feature. :slight_smile: I have even looked at the articles that influence investors and from whqt i see here… nothing about ingame ugc :smiley:


Hi @Blizzei !

I was interested in this revenue drop, so investigated it further. The experience you claim affects your revenue is BLUEBERRY’s UGC Creator. Unfortunately, the data before the 16th November is unavailable, so we will have to rely on the data from that day.

I believe this is accurate as from the 16th to the 19th have been roughly the same daily visits, with the exception of the 20th, where it was added to Today’s Picks. The average across this period was 24,000 daily visits.

On the experience, it lists a badge of if a user has published a UGC item. Roblox shows this rarity of less than 1%. Assuming this figure, along with the daily visits, 240 items were published daily over that period - which I don’t think is significant enough to cause the drop in your sales.

Interested to hear your thoughts, though.

There is badges given out for one item being created yes however people typically will publish more than one item. Even if it did show only a couple hundred people today, the previous data that isnt there is likely going to be way more than that due to hype on social media regarding these games. Also i expect it to eventually affect analytics because 2000+ obtained the badge today