Ironwood Frontier -- Game Feedback

I just finished the public release version of my passion project from over the summer.

Ironwood Frontier is a cowboy/western themed game about keeping both your character and the town alive and well.
-You can focus on getting and delivering raw materials into the town through farming, mining, hunting, and tree chopping
-You can work in the many stores to turn raw materials into usable items needs to keep players alive and working efficiently
-You can be an outlaw and rob stores, the Bank, and other players.
-You can be a bounty hunter, the Sheriff, or the mayor of the town.

Theres always something to do in this game, and much like other games its always better with more people!

Obviously I have lots of planned future updates for the game; gangs, homes, more POIs, more stores, etc. But this is the basic release of it. I ran an add with leftover money I had from an old project and it did ok. But without the ad the player stream stopped.

I know the tutorial menu isnt the best, and Im planning how to make an actual tutorial that guides your player around, since 90% of people who join walk around for 5 seconds then leave. I know its a game people will enjoy when they actually get into it, because the people I have seen stay longer than 5 seconds seem to figure it out and enjoy it.

However after working on it for months I obviously know the ins and outs of the game so Its hard to image how it looks to a brand new player. Id love some feedback on first impressions, things that work and things that could be changed, and what would make the game more appealing/welcoming to players joining for the first time, What could I change so people get drawn in right away.

Also if anyone has suggestions/advice for getting the game out there (or if anyone knows any potential investors :wink: then id be open to hearing.

But overall id love to hear some feedback from people on first impressions of the game, and what you think when playing it for the first time, and what you think would make you more likely to stick around after the first 5 seconds.

3 Likes

Your game really reminds me of a game I used to own a few years back, it was called Regicide, a game where you lived in a medieval village, there was a king, you could produce bread and do all sorts of village things, as well as kill the King to become one. What I’m trying to say is, I ultimately understand what the concept of your game is, it’s a social game that requires other people (preferably intelligent lol) to make it it work.

The game is great in itself, I can tell you developed it with a lot of care and thought, I really liked the ambience (although some music and sound design are missing which are key to keeping peole immersed).

However, as much as I understand your dreams, I may have to crush them… Unfortunately, Roblox is no longer a platform that will allow these types of games to thrive, they had great impact during the 2011 - 2014 era, where we had rational players who enjoyed thought out games over slop, personally your game would be on my top list of games if this was years ago.

I can tell that you’re new to programming in Roblox and I have to congratulate you for achieving this massive milestone which is to actually get your full fledged game out, this is amazing, congratulations! With each new project your skills will grow even more and you’ll be able to make more complex and convoluted games.

Over all, my review is biased because I really love these types of games, so I’d say your game is a 7/10 right now, what I felt is missing is an actual proper tutorial (perhaps my camera shows me the places, would be nice), because I have no idea what I can do in the game despite everything being right in front of me. Also, ambience and sounds, especially for UI, can be deal breakers when it comes to games; as of now, if I enter your game, my brain is receiving no stimulus to continue, and after taking a few steps I immediately want to leave.

If you really want to make this game work, I suggest you build a small community around it slowly, mouth-to-mouth and do game nights on Discord, add interesting mechanics to keep the server flowing like a Mayor system perhaps? (forgive me if that’s already in the game lol), so there are power dynamics and whatnot, big fan of the mailing system though lol.

1 Like

*After playing this game for around 1hr getting level 3 in mining, wood, farming, while also getting a horse, weapon and instrument, I have a few criticisms. *

  • Music & Ambience: The game really needs background music or at least ambient sounds like wind and sand blowing. The horses and buffalo are also deadly silent, and the pickaxe could be louder. I’m not sure if the lack of soundtrack is intentional or if it is to allow you to hear the tunes from the piano and instruments in the store but the silence is very off-putting to me.

  • The Mines & Farm: The Mines felt definitely feel like a WIP and I hope you make them a little more varied or interesting looking in the future. The Farm is also alright, but I found the process of farming kind of slow and annoying, I only harvested them once because of that and got to level 3.

  • World Layout & Character Appearance: I’d feel more connected to my character if I could at least customize its facial features or skin a little bit. The world in general feels kind of flat and empty, I can get the classic Old Western aesthetic that you are going for since but a little more NPC’s or some movement in the town would make it feel fuller. Being able to zoom out so far feels emersion breaking with how empty the areas around the town are.

  • Lanterns & Tools: I feel like you should be able to dual wield the lantern with other tools. I also think the tutorial button should be emphasized with a highlight and exclamation mark above it because people came into the game asking me how to play instead of finding the tutorial.

  • Shops: The Selling Menu closing after selling a product is kind of annoying, I feel like the selling menu should display your current amount of product and the amount you choose to sell so you don’t have to go back and forth from inventory to shop menu.

  • Store Supplies: I do find the fact that someone has to own the store and get supply to restock it an interesting concept, but I can see it getting annoying since there isn’t a guaranteed stream of players to take up jobs and restock stuff. You would run out and then have purchase every job that you want to restock. maybe it should restock on its own very slowly.

  • Buffalo: Why do the buffalo take me 20 shots to 53 shots to kill point blank with the cowboy shotgun, is that intentional or is it bugged? Also are they supposed to attack me because they didn’t seem to get damage me or my horse.

Overall, I think the game definitely has potential and a working gameplay loop. Just adding music and more sounds would improve my experience by 80%. I hope my criticism doesn’t come out to harshly.

1 Like

I love the ideas/critique! Thanks. A few of these are definitely things Ie thought of and either pushed off or told myself “Ill wait to see if someone mentions it”. Definitely need to work on SFX (easily my least favorite part of dev work lol). Yeah the Buffalo is on my list to fix the scaling. As of now they dont attack but im working on a few ways to set that up so its balanced/works well.

yeah Dual Wield lantern is a good idea. I had that idea a few times and I guess I was waiting for someone to actually say it lol.

Character customization is definitely high up on my list of stuff to do. Its one of the first big updates I planned on doing after release. A whole system where you can get new clothes, go out and find dyes to customize, change skin/hair etc. Only reason I didnt do it yet was because if I sat and did every idea I had this game never wouldve been published lol.

Yeah the Mines are def a WIP. I have a few outlying ones that have a bit more variety but Im going to keep workshopping new layouts/features. Parkour to get rare ores etc.

Overall I really appreciate the response!

1 Like

Im glad to hear it brought back memories. And Im quite aware of the modern trends lol. That was one of my biggest concerns when making the game was reminding myself it probably wouldve done numbers back in the day. id love to throw it on a thumbdrive and travel back to 2019 me and leave it there lol. But Yeah I know niches exist and I do believe with luck and some persistence I can maybe carve out a nice one. And if I cant, oh well. Life goes on. But I never wouldve been satisified if I never at least got the game published.

Yeah I definitely want to make an actual tutorial. One that holds the players hand and walks them through so they dont leave right away. And yes the game definitely needs more stimulus. Ive been working to find a balance between the lonely west vies/Fun community game. Im sure Ill figure it out eventually. The game definitely needs an SFX overhaul, thats my Achilles heel. Since you and someone else both mentioned it Ill make that my next focus most likely, and really get it all worked out.

I appreciate the review/comments they mean a lot and I hope they will help me improve this game as much as I can!

1 Like

Also yeah each time I go in and play the shops things bothers me. It was one of the earlier systems I made so it wasnt as refined/well done. Each time I go to sell stuff I get mad at myself for it, ill definitely add it to the list of things to rework. Again I think I just needed someone to actually say it to me.

Hello

I love the idea however I have a major problem

I played your game without reading any descriptions and I was very confused. Alot of players do not want a tutorial let alone long paragraphs of text they want engaging not having to read.

It’s very easy as the developer to know the game like the back of their hand however the player has absolutely no idea what’s going on.

The tutorial needs to engaging, this could be arrows to trees to chop down and then once they have the wood they are shown where to sell etc.

When a player opens a game you have around 30 seconds to grab their attention and if they can’t understand the game or make enough instant progress they will leave straight away.

On a positive note I love the UI and the actual game idea I feel like this could be a great game

Conclusion:
My advice is completely get rid of the tutorial and make it quick and interactive or use a quick slideshow to show what the objectives are. There also needs to be quick dopamine, by this I mean the user should be completing tasks and getting rewards in the first few minutes of the game and there should be a goal the user needs to aim for a simple ladder system

1 Like

Yeah you’re definitely right. Im working on mapping out a good way to get that done and get players right into things once they join. Ill probably keep the info setup I have just as a documentation players can reference (I may spoof it up so its cleaner/more concise) but the main tutorial that players will be prompted to do when they first play will definitely be more interactive. I planned on doing something that guides you to the mines/trees, then to a store to sell and then craft the stuff.

But I really appreciate the feedback and Im glad to hear that the main concern is about being lost when you first join. This was a problem I was worried about and now I know to go all in on addressing it.

1 Like