Is my game too punishing?

Hello all, I have been making steady improvements to my game, Team Tycoon Race, after taking a break from it for a while. The game is a race to see which team pays off an initial “debt” of $1 million by building a tycoon and fighting for money crates at the center of the map and buried underground.

One thing I am concerned about is that players may get very frustrated with the fighting system. Currently, if someone kills you with a sword or laser gun, they take all of your money, so you could potentially gain or lose very big sums of cash this way. I definitely don’t want players to be frustrated but I also don’t want to overcorrect anything that may kill incentive to use the weapons.

I’m seriously considering making it so that if someone kills you, they gain however much money you have but you still get to keep your money as well, I just don’t know if this will be a good change or how it will affect gameplay. What do you guys think?

The game is here:

I wouldn’t go with the keeping your money when you die idea as this would probably cause farming.
What about if you die, you lose half of your money to the player who killed you?

The fact that players lose all of there money on death can and will lead certain player getting frustrated and leaving there server and changing it or just leaving for good without coming back.
What you could try is to only remove half of the money or, what I think its better, use a random system to take a random percentage between 1% and 50% at every deaths.

I think this might damage your game’s economy? Let’s say Player A and Player B are teaming. Player A has 5,000 cash, Player B has 0. Player A lets Player B kill them continuously, and then Player A kills Player B which will effectively duplicate their cash how many times Player B claimed from them.



I agree with @Dago2812, maybe a specific percentage should be gained and reducted from the target’s account. This way, players won’t be as frustrated at the fact they’ve got to save up all their hard work because somebody keeps taking their money.

How about just taking a % of the players cash? Motivates players to use the weapons while also giving them a less harsh punishment if they die.

You’re definitely right that it would lead to farming, and I have implemented @Zerv_Zen 's solution of taking only half. An interesting feature of this, I think, is that I can make unique powerups that manipulate this percentage.