Hello, I just released one of my games and I would like feedback on what works and what does not. Just play through and tell me what you like, what you didnt like, what made you want to leave, etc. The game is about diving for sea creatures and collecting rarer and rarer fish. Thanks!
Hey! Overall, I think your game is really good! It’s quite clear what you’re supposed to do (apart from the Gear button during the initial tutorial), and I really like the progression of going deeper into the ocean to find better items.
Small Suggestions
- The Gear button in the tutorial could be more clearly highlighted.
- I’d make the fish larger, especially thicker, so they’re easier to click.
- It would be helpful if fish glowed gold when you’re close enough to interact with them.
- The arrow pointing towards the dock is visible underwater, but it’s quite difficult to see. I’d suggest adding a small directional arrow close to the player showing which way to swim.
- Hatching eggs takes quite a long time. Perhaps players could hatch multiple eggs simultaneously when purchasing several at once?
Game Presentation
- I really like your thumbnails! However, I’d recommend adding a short gameplay video to give potential players a better idea of what the game is about.
- I’d also consider shortening the game description significantly. It currently feels a little generic, perhaps AI-generated. Features like rebirth aren’t particularly interesting to highlight in the description. I’d focus on a very short, engaging explanation of the core gameplay instead.
Other Thoughts
Personally, I’m not a huge fan of the GUI. I think it looks a little plain and generic, although this is obviously subjective.
I also wonder whether you could introduce some vehicles, such as a submarine, that players could purchase. I personally rarely spend Robux, but I think something like that could be an interesting addition.
A Few Questions
I’m curious about your player statistics:
- What’s the average playtime?
- Do you have a custom analytics system in the game?
- Do you track median playtime separately from average playtime?
- How long do players typically stay in the game?
Feedback on My Game
I’d really appreciate it if you could also check out my game and share some honest feedback!
My biggest challenge right now is player retention. A lot of players leave within the first 10 minutes, so I’d especially appreciate feedback on the early-game experience, what could be confusing, and what might make players want to keep playing.
Farmers Valley: Farmers Valley - Farm with Friends | Play on Roblox
Thank you for the feedback! In terms of your game at least as first impressions the problems I see lie with visuals and dopamine. Right now I dont feel enough satisfaction when selling, harvesting, or planting, it feels boring instead of exciting. Along with this overall visuals I would say could be improved in terms of buildings and crops. These are just first impressions but visual for me would be the main drawback.