Mass Ban False Positives

I can’t believe I have to report this, but your automated moderation system is mass banning legitimate developers for “ban evasion” when they’ve never even evaded any bans. The automated system is incorrectly chaining (or something similar ) unrelated moderation events into false “ban evasion” violations, resulting in account terminations.

A while ago I uploaded a basic hallway and room model for a maze generation module which got moderated but was later reverted when I appealed, but my Account was SIMULTANEOUSLY terminated for “ban evasion” at identical timestamp (06:36 PM GMT) and all my appeals so far have been rejected by ai without human response even after being escalated into top devs.

After looking into it I realized I’m not the only one with by the looks of 50+ posts about it on r/RobloxHelp with “Ban Help” tag, and multiple videos made about it: https://youtu.be/Fr4l6hxZvuU?t=445&si=kJIJESeiA98dFs_B https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K9zQU6CRc-8

I believe the issue occurred because I was on college WiFi when the ban happened. The system detected the shared IP address and assumed I was a banned user evading on an alt account, triggering the “ban evasion” termination at the exact same timestamp as the model flag (12/15/25 06:36 PM GMT). Even though my model appeal was accepted and the violation reversed, the account termination remains active because the moderation systems aren’t idk communicating with each other ¯_(ツ)_/¯.

For EU users like myself, I’m pretty sure this also violates Digital Services Act Article 20(6), which requires that moderation decisions be taken under human supervision and “not solely on the basis of automated means.”



Expected behavior

For users who were falsely banned to have the moderation action reverted.

A private message is associated with this bug report

Thanks for your report. Can you try appealing via our standard channels? If your account was incorrectly associated with another account, the best way to appeal this is via the support form > Appeal a Decision > I was moderated for my behavior or the behavior of an alt account.

And if one of your alt accounts DID get incorrectly moderated, then you should appeal the violation from that account

Sorry, didn’t mean to close the topic so quickly – the team did check our systems, and the systems are working as expected. The best course of action is to appeal the alt association, if none of your alt accounts were moderated

Hi! Could I be updated on this?

Hello,

I believe that there is a big mistake being made regarding the entire “ban evasion” moderation system. A lot of people including myself have been terminated, with ban enforcement being used as a reason.

COMPLAINTS:

I’ll list a couple of the complaints I have with the current system so far:

  1. The AI moderation appears to be way too sensitive. I’ve been looking into the DevForum and outside, and the amount of people being falsely terminated for an “enforcement ban” is huge.

  2. The automatic moderation action appears to be taken solely based on a user’s IP address. This means that people who use a VPN (like myself) are getting instantly unfairly targetted by the system and being terminated. This is also the case for households where brothers/sisters play on different accounts, and for people who use public a WiFi.

  3. The appeal team seems to be ignoring all evidence when it comes to reviewing cases. For more information I have made an exhaustive post (linked in the paragraph below) detailing my entire appeal process, and how I am still being rejected, despite the fact that the appeal team cannot provide any proof as to how I went against the rules. I am not the only case, a small search online would show the enormous amount of people that require tens of appeals before being unbanned. I have not been lucky enough to get reinstated so far.

Here is the DevForum post in question (the 26th Reply) where I explain in detail, with e-mail screenshots, about my appeal process: FALSE Termination, due to VPN - #26 by furno58

Sorry if some of my replies (or others’) appear to be a bit “taunting” at times, but you have to understand that it is, for many of us, the loss of literally thousands of hours of development progress on the account, and hundreds if not thousands of dollars worth of Robux + assets. When receiving the kind of replies I show in that post, we can’t help but feel extremely disrespected by the platform moderation.


IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS
I will list you some suggestions that I have myself, and some that I’ve found while reading other people which I found interesting.

  1. Account termination should only be for extreme cases. An account (that may contain hundreds of dollars/hours worth of development) should not get terminated based on a situation that does not have a strong enough factual basis. In fact, this should be limited to real cases of “sabotage” of the platform, or illegal actions that users have performed.

  2. Account termination should always be performed by a human moderator. We understand that Roblox has a huge traffic of moderation requests daily due to the platform size, but entrusting an AI with account termination is the best recipe for an absolute disaster. If these moderation actions were 1 to 7 days long, and did not impact the long term standing of the account in case of future moderation, we would’ve been a lot more okay with mistakes being made while systems are being implemented. This, however, is not the case currently.

  3. Enforcement bans, specifically, must either be changed in the way they detect behavior, or be completely removed altogether. As I’ve explained above, there is very strong evidence to the fact that enforcement ban only uses IP as the sole information to ban a user. This is the perfect scenario for a ban wave with a majority of false positives. It represents a problem for people who:

    • Use VPNs (like myself)
    • Use a public WiFi (even once)
    • Live in the same household as other users who’ve been banned
  4. Appeal teams should really base their actions on factual evidence rather than deciding based on random factors (as it seems to currently be the case, as shown in my detailed linked post above). This is beneficial for both the appeal team, and the users: if I, and the many other falsely banned people, were taken seriously and reinstated, the amount of appeal messages that the moderation received would’ve been far lower. Every time they ignore one of our appeal, or make a random decision, they are simply putting us in a position where we have to send even more appeal messages.


The best way I could describe the current state of moderation is as if you were randomly accused of a crime that you did not commit, and that you are being asked to prove your innocence with substantial proof, all while there is no actual evidence for the accusation in the first place. You have, basically, NO way of proving your innocence, because you are considered “guilty until proven innocent”.

If you could get some of these issues noticed by the relevant staff who are in charge of the respective issues, it would be beneficial for absolutely everyone involved, and I thank you in advance for doing it.

From what I’ve seen, the issue really doesn’t seem to be an operational issue or system level issue, but an issue with the way that moderation action is carried out. For example, multiple accounts operating within the same environment could be affected at the same time, even if only one account faced the original moderation action. Multiple people using separate accounts within the same household environment, or in a school or public setting could appear linked although they are unrelated.

Any updates? did you get your account back? something similar happened to a friend of mine

“working as expected” its not april 1st bro