Need feedback on my new game before I hire more devs!

Hello, I am working on a new game that I think has lots of potential in terms of gameplay, fun, and replayability. I want to hire new devs but I think I should get some people to confirm my thoughts on the games potential, below is what the game is about.

Cookie crafters (temporary name) is a game about going shopping for 14 ingredients of increasing rarity, with these ingredients you can craft 100 different cookies that all have a unique recipe and value. Choose how long you want to bake your cookies for to get cool mutations, buy better baskets for luck and collection speed, and eventually discover all the cookies in the game!

If you want to give me feedback then please do so as it will be greatly appreciated, thanks! :smiley:

Game link: Cookie crafters - Roblox

1 Like

I played it and then got confused. This game BADLY needs a tutorial.
Here is a list of things I’m confused on:

  • How do you make money?
  • How to you craft cookies?

If players join in and are instantly confused, there just going to leave instantly.

Also, I would recommend making better UI, because I clicked the UI buttons, and the open frames do not match the button style. On top of that, the game needs an icon, and a few thumbnails.

Yes, my next addition to the game is a tutorial and I was in fact working on it before you replied. The reason the GUI was bad was because I only just found a GUI designer this morning and hes been at school so there was no work on that. Thanks!

1 Like

Work on the onboarding first before making such posts i have no idea what to do

1 Like

One would assume that a game called “Cookie Crafters” would have a station where you could… craft cookies, like a kitchen or something?