for those who do not know, the minimum age to join the DevForum is 13.
despite this, however, we have seen several little kid accounts over the past couple months.
for example, there was this kid on an account who doxxed their own home and details because they didn’t know internet safety, and there was another kid who just constantly spammed posts until they got banned.
for forum moderators, please add a new report type (“User is underage”), so that we can report these kids. nobody under 13 should be on the forum
The problem is that moderators can’t be 100% sure someone is underage without solid evidence, since false positives are always possible. Even if we already know that this user is underage (@Unicornpops77737 I’m talking about you and your past and future alts you’ll make), moderators still need conclusive evidence to justify a ban. They can’t just ban someone based on their mannerisms, how they write, or what they do.
If I could ban this user right now, I would, because I already know they’re underage. However, from a moderation standpoint, banning them without sufficient evidence would be a bad decision. This remains true even if they post images that their past alt accounts also posted or communicate in the exact same way as those accounts. These things can raise suspicion, but moderators still need evidence strong enough to justify taking action.
The only way people are getting banned for being underage if they personally post any sort of evidence anywhere on roblox (devforum or main site).
And no, posting a web.roblox link doesn’t count because there was a huge number of very obviously young kids on here a long time ago, and no matter how many web.roblox links they posted the mods would without fail come back and say “oh well uhhh anyone can post those lol”
I know that the devforum is actually a surprisingly child safe place compared to the main website, but the famous Roblox motto still unfortunately applies here:
What if it was integrated to the roblox age verification system, so your roblox account is directly linked to the devforum profile by something like a RobloxPlayerAgeGroup link.
On Devforum you wouldn’t be able to touch the age settings, which is only avaliable via the Roblox Player client.
The website is already hard coded to disallow accounts under 13 (regardless of verification status if any. If it says it’s under 13 it’s treated as such.) it’s just that those kids always use alts/throwaways specifically to get around the age filter (because the devforum just checks if the birthdate is set to be over 13 years old, they only need to make a new account and that’s it)
I don’t feel like gating by age is fair in this matter. On one hand, your average 13 year old may be silly and undereducated, but another one could be well spoken, intelligent and full of learning potential. Let’s not harm the few people that truly matter here trying to solve the majority.
reading comprehension
also may as well state an idea i saw which actually WOULD be useful and wouldn’t require pure id verification:
this can actually be used w/o id verification and theres like heaps of evidence ive seen of people being underage on the forum yet not getting banned for it
issue is that 13 year olds, silly or not, really do not act like that, they at least know what the devforum is for
half of the people i’ve seen that are underage, usually less than 11, don’t even know what the forum is for and treat it like it’s the 2017 roblox forums
Underage users sort themselves out very quickly. I honestly don’t consider it a pressing issue, and it’s not one that can be solved without age verification.