Prevent banned users from downvoting the game

Banned users are able to down vote a game even when a ban is active, this is an issue since most people that get banned will most likely down vote the game in pure spite.

I have tested this with my own accounts and I could change the up vote to a down vote.

This is problematic since it limits the usefulness of the Roblox provided ban feature.

We will most likely not use the ban feature due to this and instead reset the players stats if they have used exploits to gain advantages in the game.

This sounds like a horrible idea and could easily be abused by developers with malicious intentions (more specifically people like scammers, for example) if you could just ban someone to prevent them from rating it negatively after they realize there’s something wrong with the game.

Banned players unfairly downvoting your game should be a non-issue to begin with, and even if it is provably an issue there are definitely far better ways for Roblox to handle it than to introduce something with such a great potential for abuse.

One of my games went from around 40 dislikes up to over 400 because I banned a bunch of hackers and broke their hacks. It is a very real and very bad problem.
image
Mind you, most of the dislikes came after I banned all the hackers and fixed the hack.

I think preventing users from voting on a game while they’re banned is a good idea. If they had already liked or disliked the game before being banned, it should stay.
In the case someone gets banned and then dislikes it, it gets really annoying since they disliked it because they got banned, not for any actual good reason.
Allowing banned users to vote on games often does nothing but harm the game.

Also, don’t you think its a little unrealistic to think that a random developer of a random game is going to go ban anyone they think might have a negative opinion about something? Most people who actually vote on games are silent, there’s almost no way to tell if someone dislikes something unless they’re vocal about it.

Thank you for providing this clear example, this is what I fear from banning people.

If they have down voted before the ban happens I am perfectly fine with the down vote being there.

My theoretical scenario here is the case of scammers creating a game. With the system this user is proposing the scammer could immediately ban the user the moment they’ve fallen prey to the scam to prevent them from downvoting the game and hopefully giving a heads up to other users that it’s a sketchy game.

And even then on another note, realistically if these users went to the effort of downvoting the game, then is preventing banned users from voting really going to do anything when they will almost definitely create alt accounts or just bot the dislikes instead? There just seems to be way too many flaws with this approach than there are benefits.

Maybe, but this seems like a bit of a stretch. Game developers would need to actively be playing their game among all servers unless they were to automate the banning using the API. I feel at that point it should instead be flagged as suspicious behavior on the side of Roblox moderation. I could see scummy developers running scam obbies or the like, but generally these are things that Roblox eventually removes from the platform anyways regardless of the games user ratings.

With that said I don’t think banning a player should retroactively remove their rating of the game, so only a 1 way blocking system for potential abuse of the rating system.

And just to give some context to the magnitude of the issue when it comes to banning people.

In Strongman Ultra we had an exploit where you could gain energy very fast, this exploit was up for about 12 hours and at least 600 players manage to use it during that time frame.

Banning 600+ players in a game that has 2k votes in total would not be pretty for the rating.

I feel like the best take could be mainly accounts that are either new, or haven’t played the game for a specific time – to limit the amount of dislikes that could be made.

It’s hard to really say that a “banned player” doesn’t at least sometimes deserve the right to dislike if the game-creator, or etc. Might be causing problems, or the game might feel buggy – and the user might happen to dislike the game for how it works.

I would definitely recommend alternatives, more so because sometimes it doesn’t need to be just a game-dev, or one person, but rather a whole team who can take action against people who are constructively criticizing.

Why hasn’t this been added yet?!

It’s simple. When users are banned (usually justified by bad behavior), they shall no longer be able to change their rating of the game.

I don’t see how this could possibly be exploited. It’s not really an issue that you liked a game and are unable to unlike it, since you performed unwanted behavior or the creator simply dislikes you.

This is such a big issue, but there’s no real way to fix it without having a ton of potential safety risks or potential ways to abuse/rig voting

Support, someone in the community is making a bunch of alts everyday to downvote my game + leave troll feedback in retaliation to a DMCA I filed.

Roblox doesn’t specify who disliked their game, which means the developer can’t just “ban” them.

The positives out weigh the negatives.

Sure, it will help scam games, but it will also help literally every other game on Roblox.

They should still be able to report the game. If mods are active it can get taken down entirely which is much better than trying to communicate through likes/dislikes.

Though I don’t think it really matters restricting who can like/dislike. If the game is fun the likes will eventually outweigh the dislikes.

Strongly agreeing with the OP. I was Leading development for a game and upon release our competitors were exploiting, and if we’d ban them they’ve would’ve disliked the game and created a new account. And doing the same loop once again resulting in several tens of dislikes just from alts.

Keyword: Theoretical.
You’re only providing ONE negative example and pushing it to its absolute extremes (Assuming no one will notice its a scam before falling for it) and being banned before they can downvote it, as well as the fact that the games rating itself would be incredibly suspicious because of how weirdly positive it is.

People who notice this theoretical game is a scam will leave and maybe dislike it, meaning they don’t get banned since they don’t fall for it, and their rating still goes through.

Again, you’re pushing it to absolute extremes here. I LOVE hating things, I am extremely petty but even I’m not bothered creating alts with the sole purpose of disliking games since you have to be email verified to vote on games, and its also in general just really annoying to switch between alts.

Your examples only work when pushed to extremes, in practice this would be a good change, again, it is a very real and very bad problem that exists.

They should also make it so you have to play a game for Atleast an hour before you can dislike.

There is a specific person who posted on a specific platform telling people to dislike bomb my game, which has caused it to drop to a 76% rating.

10-15 minutes should be good enough on its own to determine that someone has played long enough to have a good idea of the gameplay. A whole hour is absurd and would heavily rig like/dislikes.

It was just an example, 10 mins is better tho