Roblox: Is this game idea good?

Help and Feedback Creations Feedback
#1

Hello, I’m Astraminy!

I’m working on a psychological survival game with a heavy theme of identity fraud. The game Idea is that you and X amount of player’s who joined you are each in they own separate room filled with fake people who also joined you.

The game would go like this: You complete experiment’s with the “Fake people” (which you still think are real people who joined you). Each experiment you do another more deranged one would start with the “Fake people” around you becoming more deranged and robot-like.

The ending would most likely be some sort of choosing who is real and who is not to win.

Screenshot's of WIP Lobby of Game

RobloxScreenShot20250214_230917034
RobloxScreenShot20250214_2309170341199×613 52.1 KB

RobloxScreenShot20250215_201033075
RobloxScreenShot20250215_2010330751199×613 52 KB

Is this a good game Idea? Vote here:

  • Would Play
  • Won’t Play

0 voters

4 Likes
#2

Seams like a pretty cool idea for a game, one question tho. Would the “fake people” have the same avatars as the real ones that joined? For example 6 people joined one lobby they got split up 3 and 3 would each side of 3 real people have 3 fake people but with the skins of the other real people who got separated from? If that makes sense…

#3

Each real player would have to be separated from one another. Due to the “fake players” would all be client sided for performance.

And yes, the “fake players” will mimic everybody that has joined that game.

1 Like
#4

Thanks, I appreciate the fast response. Excited to see what comes from this idea.:+1:

1 Like
#5

Just something to note, you shouldnt be asking us if we would play your game, ( example the poll you made).

Why? Because chances are we are NOT your target audience, which would result in information telling you well people wouldntplay it.

The only people you should ask if they would play your game is your target audience, no one else.

Anyhow me ranting aside, this could defiantly work! I think its a pretty cool idea that people might enjoy.

Best of luck!

1 Like
#6

heeeheehaaha now the big companies are gonna steal your idea you shoulda kept it private

2 Likes
#7

I really like this idea and would probably play with my friends. Just one question though, would you be disabling chat so that overhead chat messages don’t point out who is the real player? Also similarly, how would you combat the VC icon not showing up above the players’ heads?

1 Like
#8

Yeah I understand and I’ll take that into account next time. But I value your opinion’s either way :ok_hand:

1 Like
#9

  1. The NPC’s already have a way to communicate in chat / bubble chat. The chats only appear client sided so only you can read what they say and all the player’s will be separated from each other. :+1:

  2. VC would be a pretty big problem. If they is a way to make the player’s VC be anywhere then I would make it so the VC positions to one of the assigned “Fake Players”. But if that is currently not capable then I will just be forced to disable VC. Either way I’m going to look into that now because that’s pretty important.

1 Like
#10

dangit :pensive:

I appreciate that the Idea is good enough to be stolen. But the whole idea of Identity fraud in ROBLOX is pretty barren so I should be good.

Come to think of it I can only name one game that incorporates fake players into their game. Which is “Identity fraud”. And even if they are more like that, I’m going for something a bit more advanced with the whole “Fake Players”. Because the whole Idea is to fool you into thinking they are real.