Silly knock stuff down game: looking for feedback

I made a game where you knock down stuff (from little items to buildings) and NPCs keep repairing them. It’s a little mindless but hopefully fun.

Any feedback at all would be appreciated. Thanks!

5 Likes
  • Is your game inspired by some other game(-s)? What makes your game unique?
  • What makes your game fun?
2 Likes
  • It’s not really inspired by another game. I was working on a totally different game in which I saw that players were enjoying knocking things down and watching them get repaired, even though this was not at all the point of that game. So I decided to build a game focused just on knocking things down. The “watching them get repaired” part is also something that I needed in the original game and which I realized was fun for people - it’s more alive than just having things magically restored.
  • Destroying things is fun. I used to play GTA just for the chance to wreck cars. Having an army of NPCs work diligently, efficiently and without complaint repairing the damage is fun to watch too. And it’s fun to explore the world and see what else I can knock down. I am still working on expanding the map.
2 Likes

Thank you for your answers.

They intrigued me, so I hopped in, let’s see what we got, my overview of your game:

:green_circle: Uniqueness
:yellow_circle: Fun
:green_circle: Simple to understand
:green_circle: Gets to the main action quickly

.

:yellow_circle: - needs improvement
:green_circle: - good

I could explain a bit, but there could be criticism you probably won’t like. Let’s leave it here, shall we? Or are you willing to proceed?!

3 Likes

Please do proceed! If it’s doomed it’s doomed. I’ll deal with it :slight_smile:

1 Like

What I will say is just my guess, I may be wrong:

I played only for a short time, but the game was a bit boring, not gonna lie.

Think about it: “I knock down an object, and then it gets put into place”, is that fun enough to be the whole core of the game?

Even if you have something more interesting further in the game, I think, at first, you need to grab attention of players quicker than that.

2 Likes

Games cool, wish you had used proper physics. Everything falls apart the same way, the first time I knocked down a fence I went “neat!” the 2nd time… the 5th… 10th… :skull:

2 Likes

Atm It feels like the grind mechanics are carrying a bit too much weight for the core gameplay loop. If you want to appeal to players who love chaos and destruction, you could give them more tools to be creative with their playstyle.

On the flip side, if you’re targeting the crowd that genuinely likes to grind, then you need a deep, structured progression mechanic like a proper job system. Right now, the game feels stuck in the middle. My advice is to pick which player profile you’re going for and lean into it.

I recommend the chaos type, the consequences are the fun part. There could be consequences. Have an angry mob chase you while you throw fences and furniture at them or something.

3 Likes