SmoothPlastic specular inconsistent when using Humanoids or Decals/Textures

Hello,

In my Roblox places, when using the SmoothPlastic material within a Humanoid, or when a Decal/Texture is rendered onto the part, the specular highlight is blown-out and looks extremely ugly and unsightly, particularly whilst using ColorGradingEffect with TonemapperPreset set to Enum.TonemapperPreset.Retro.

This has been an extremely jarring visual peculiarity for me as someone who notices small details very easily, and I would appreciate it if the behaviour could be fixed so that it is consistent between both textured and untextured states. It makes SmoothPlastic look more like the “Ice” material than its historic look/design.

This issue first started occurring in December 2019 when PBR rendering was introduced, but has never been fixed.

It’s worth noting that things don’t look as ugly without ColorGradingEffect being used, but they still don’t match the material’s regular appearance without the aforementioned instances. Even this, however, is desirable to the look currently seen with Enum.TonemapperPreset.Retro.

However, this is not a viable workaround, as I strongly favour the colour tones gained from using ColorGradingEffect overall.

I’ve provided system information below as per the guidelines, though this issue occurs on any device that you can play Roblox on.

System Information
CPU- Intel(R) Core™ i5-8265U CPU @ 1.60GHz
RAM- 8GB
GPU- Intel(R) UHD Graphics 620
OS- Windows 10 64-bit (10.0.19045)

Reproduction place file

smoothplastic.rbxl (72.4 KB)

Expected behavior

What I would expect to happen is the behaviour prior to December 2019’s PBR addition, or rather, the behaviour that seemingly remains in-place today when Humanoids and Decals/Textures are not present. This can be seen below.

As you can see, unlike before, the material renders correctly. However, this is not a viable workaround, particularly when textures are involved.

The issue does not occur with other materials, including Plastic. It also doesn’t occur if SmoothPlastic is used outside of a Humanoid or without a Decal applied.

It also used to consistently render correctly in every scenario before PBR rendering was introduced. I personally suspect the issue was never dealt with, due to the reproduction steps being fairly obscure and because Roblox was more focused with concerning visual fidelity at the time with what was then the Voxel and ShadowMap lighting modes.

To add on, here’s another example of the issue using sphere parts.

The one on the left has a number of Decals applied to match the specific “Sea green” colour of the sphere on the right, which is untextured. As you can see, the specular highlight is blown-out and looks extremely ugly on the left-hand sphere.

Here’s an image without ColorGradingEffect…

The specular highlight behaviour is still inconsistent for SmoothPlastic here, but it doesn’t result in the highlight becoming blown-out in the same way. However, this arguably should also be corrected, as it’s a strange inconsistency that doesn’t present in any other materials.

The expected behaviour is that both would match, as can be seen in the following screenshot taken in a 2019 Roblox build.

Bumping this as this issue is still occurring for me and (I suspect) most users. Only other detail that’s worth adding is that this issue does not affect the Gouraud shading used on graphics levels 1 and 2.