Team can't decide which game idea to go with, please vote which one we should go with

Help and Feedback Game Design Support
#1

Hi. Sorry if this isn’t the correct category, I’m new to this. Anyways, we are a team of some new scripters/builders all from a common server. We decided to make a game to have a common goal to increase our scripting knowledge and ability. We currently can’t decide between the two ideas. 2 of us want one, 2 want the other. Can you please vote on the game you’d rather see on Roblox?

These are the two ideas. If you have any feedback for either game, please share below.

  • Game 1
  • Game 2

0 voters

Game 2 Won. Description deleted as we’d prefer less-than-honest people not to steal our ideas. Thanks for your time.

5 Likes
#2

Very cool ideas! I personally voted for Game 1, as I think it would be very entertaining. I know there are a lot of apocalyptic themed games around so I feel like you would get a lot of competition.

Best of luck to which ever game idea you go with, and I look forward to seeing it develop!

3 Likes
#3

Haha thanks! We decided whichever loses could be our next project, if it is a close second.

2 Likes
#4

Let’s see what our team is going to make. Quite interesting to see people voting.

1 Like
#5

I voted for 2

(allthoguh i would fix the badges and control points)

#6

I like option two. These both are great game ideas, but I have voted for option two.

#7

1 more Vote please! Number has to be odd!

1 Like
#8

Nice ideas, however you should keep in mind your target audience. Personally, the first game idea sounds pretty interesting, but I’m not sure if younger kids would play it. They prefer more straightforward games that don’t require too much thinking. Second game would probably attract little kids more but it’s ultimately up to you guys.

2 Likes