I have tried adding textures and different shapes + playing games like tomb raider for inspiraiton.
What I really need is reference photos and specific advice and suggestions.
I appreciate any advice or reference suggestions people have/find.
Given how nobody else has replied to this, I’ll give it a shot. So what I think is that the one on the left is fine in terms of size and shape, but for the one on the right, unless you’re going to add any more text, I think you could make it smaller. What I think could make it better is if you added a the same glowing color on the border in place of that grey border, or separately a little more inside of it.
You’res still doesn’t adress making it look magical while old, fitting in with the mystical surroundings.
So I had a go on my own after doing a sketch or two and this is what i’ve done.
I’d love your feedback and would appreciate any advice on making this more old and mystical to fit in with “whence it came”.