Tween working for everything else but not for the middle button

I have a tween which makes my buttons fade in but the settings button just fades in but the button turns white while everything else doesn’t.
image

playerui = game.Players.LocalPlayer.PlayerGui
Menu_ButtonGoal = {BackgroundTransparency = 0}
local MenuButtons = TweenInfo.new(2)

Play_Button = playerui.MenuUI.Frame.Settings.Text

Credit_Button = playerui.MenuUI.Frame.Settings.Text

Settings_Button = playerui.MenuUI.Frame.Settings.Text

local SettingsButtonTween = tween:Create(Settings_Button, MenuButtons, Menu_ButtonGoal)
local CreditButtonTween = tween:Create(Credit_Button, MenuButtons, Menu_ButtonGoal)
local PlayButtonTween = tween:Create(Play_Button, MenuButtons, Menu_ButtonGoal)

CreditButtonTween:Play()
PlayButtonTween:Play()
SettingsButtonTween:Play()

here is my UI layout:
image

Maybe the background transparency for all of the buttons are not set to 0?

its set to 1 for every button and when the tween plays it is supposed to go to 0

Ah, what is this?

Play_Button = playerui.MenuUI.Frame.Settings.Text

Credit_Button = playerui.MenuUI.Frame.Settings.Text

Settings_Button = playerui.MenuUI.Frame.Settings.Text

Why are they all set to “Settings”?