What should I do with my idea

Help and Feedback Game Design Support
#1

Please correct me if this is the wrong category

So, I have been making a game for the last month, and I just thought about how generic it is.

My idea was making a anime-styled fighting game that was inspired from Rivals.
Ofc again, generic.

So now I’m wondering what I should do.

I had another idea for an open world, game that took inspiration from hollow knight, and deepwoken. but I wanted to just go for a darker theme, that was more focused on the story.
And by story no I don’t mean reading dialogue for 50 years, but more of just witnessing the stuff around you, which the game delves into the themes of grief and what not.

Along with that theres also going to be PvP, or PvE, cause well, I like fighting lol.
My main concern is it being to generic, so I would like some advice on how I can steer clear of that.

Also would this game like, work? Roblox might not be the best place for a less light hearted game

Any ideas?
I really just need your thoughts cause I’m second guessing everything lol~
~ Frodev

1 Like
#2

I mean, I like the idea of a story based game, but then I dont think people under the age of ten would be able to play it. On the pvp idea, maybe add in some sorta cool mechanic, or theme the game around something unique

#3

Hmm yeah I could probably do that, I might go with the second idea I had, cause thinking about it, it sounds cool lol

1 Like
#4

I think you should merge the ideas. Make an anime-themed game that has equal parts of lore and fighting. It would work!

1 Like
#5

I like this idea. I was playing rivals recently, and I was thinking of how can I make it better.

1 Like