Which Game Idea Sounds Better? (Quick Feedback Wanted)

Help and Feedback Creations Feedback
, ,
1

Hey! I’m deciding between a few Roblox game ideas and would love your opinion.

:man_climbing: 1. Ascendia – Infinite Climb Obby
Climb as high as you can. Random obby chunks, checkpoints, leaderboards, and fun tools (like grapples or balloons).

:soap: 2. Clean It – Mindful Cleaning Game
Relaxing game where you clean up a dirty world. Satisfying visuals, daily dirt reset, and calming zones with cosmetic rewards.

:memo: 3. Leave a Note – Social Message World
Players explore and leave short notes or drawings for others to find. Notes can be liked, replied to, or featured.

Which would you want to play or make?
Any quick feedback is super appreciated!

5 Likes
2

Number 1 sounds like a fun programming challenge. Would probably shoot for a deterministic render, rather than each lobby having their own Obby. That way the community can come together to solve unexplored parts of the Obby.
Number 2 has been done (On Steam: House Cleaning Survival, Powerwash Simulator, Pool Cleaning Simulator, etc), and is a successful model.
Number 3 seems like a moderation nightmare, plus I am struggling to see the point.

1 Like
3

Yeah I agree with you pressure washing simulator already was able to pull off number 2 pretty well just like many other games.

4

All of these ideas have been done before. I think you’d have more luck if you tried something slightly more unique, or if you added a unique twist to a proven game concept

5

Number 2 has definitely been done multiple times on other platforms, but there’s also Cleaning Simulator on Roblox which has the exact same requirements in it that Starmitly wants.

I’m not saying you shouldn’t try it, it’s just not an original idea.

1 Like
6

Should I go for number 1 then. Kinda like steep steps but everytime the player joins the mountain is randomizer obstacles?

1 Like