Which of these UIs should I use?

Help and Feedback Creations Feedback
1

Hi, :happy4:

I started working on the user interface for my new game – as a BEGINNER in UI design
(I started learning how to create a good user interface yesterday)

–

so I created a few buttons and frames, but the problem is with the frames – specifically, which one to choose as my basic design, :ohmy:

so I’m asking you which one you like better or think looks best. I didn’t want to make the user interface exactly the same as in simulator games (PS99, Grow a Garden, etc.), but it’s quite difficult.

IMPORTANT: I want the user interface design to be the same as in simulator games. (So basically a cartoon style, lol)

Here are the designs I created:

1
1462×418 30.6 KB

2
2489×449 30.1 KB

3
3503×423 41.7 KB

4
4490×421 36.9 KB

Please feel free to give your honest opinion, criticize if necessary, and suggest changes :happy1:

Thank you! :wink:
(I am currently compiling a whole set of these UIs, so I may come up with something better in the end)

4 Likes
2

I like the bottom right UI the best

a3c87feecec63196b9b06107d6fdaf7a5016f808
a3c87feecec63196b9b06107d6fdaf7a5016f808490×421 36.9 KB

Possibly make the stroke thinner for “Design”

6 Likes
3

Bottom left is my personal favorite, you can replace the texture with something that has to do with the frame like if it is a part shop menu have that texture but more visible and if it’s something else like a purchasing in game money with robux have the top part green and like tiny money textures or something.

You could also just make the texture more visible and remove the UICorner so it matches the grow a garden style a bit and I know players like that style a ton

2 Likes
4

Use bottom left or right, it has a simple cartoon vibe that fits great.

3 Likes
5

All of these UIs look awesome! Great job on them all! I recommend using the bottom right fourth one, I think it looks the best. How long did it take to create all of these?

2 Likes
6

Hi, sorry for the late reply, lol, it took me about an hour – the main problem was that I didn’t know how to design the buttons properly, and that took me a lot of time.