Hello, recently i made some trees in blender, and i made 4 different versions of one tree, and i am wondering which one is the best, and possibly how to make it better.
thanks!
0 voters
UPDATE: Here are some updated trees i made from your feedback!
I’d say “Four Pieces” is the best.
I personally believe that the Four Pieces tree looks the best. However, I think the trunk of each tree needs to be a little skinnier. Otherwise, good work!
Like others have suggested above, “Four Pieces” has the right balance of everything. It is the best.
Also, if you would like to, you can set up a poll so that you can easily view what the most popular choice is.
Ok, good idea it is added!
ok i have reached the thirty character text limit now i think
I agree with @AndrewsDeving101, @skizem and @TheCarbyneUniverse that the “Four Pieces“ tree looks the best. Personally, I think it’s better proportioned than the other options.
In regards to possible improvements, I think alternating the vertical rotation of each octagonal segment of the tree would make it look more natural. At the moment, each segment lines up perfectly, drawing attention to the fact that they’re all the same shape.
Four pieces. Keep in mind, trees don’t have to be so uniform. Personally, I’d rotate each layer of leaves. It’s all up to you.
Since you made them in blender, you should select the top layer of leaves, loop cut, and maybe scale it in a bit. This will make the top part thinner than the rest and create a more stylized look.
Four piece looks really nice. Your models don’t have to be just in the same pattern. You can make any of your builds unique, but it is up to you.
It’s kind of hard to distinguish the differences on a plain baseplate with nothing else around. Perhaps you could post some pictures of them on grass or wherever you want to use them? That would really help us decide.
Edit: You can also use all 4 in the game. There’s nothing wrong in variation. 
Ok 1 sec ill put something together, also good idea!
i put some things together quickly to make this, hopefully it helps!
from left to right:
1 = each piece taller
2 = 4 piece
3 = tall top
4 = Normal
I like all 4 lol, but the one to the left is probably to prefer. The two to the right are a bit too bright in my opinion, but some color adjustments and I think you could include all 4.
I think the 4 pieces tree looks the best but the taller top tree is pretty good too. Overall they all look very nice 
and I wish you good luck on your future projects!
The “Four Pieces” tree looks the best in my opinion.