You can give experience permission on any asset

[Sylmat]

This issue only seem to be when giving access to experiences, adding collaborators doesn’t let you (or at least shows you an error message)

Page URL: https://create.roblox.com/dashboard/creations/store/9114462110/permissions

[lvyachao (boocatisbest)]

Hi,

I cannot reproduce this, both permission page and configure page gave me “You need permission to access content”, I also did tried some other random assets in creator store, none of them works for me. So a few questions:

1. is that permission page always available to you for other random assets in store?
2. Do you got edit permission for this audio before?
3. for the experience grant page, the experience id you gave, do you has edit permission for that experience?

Bests

[Sylmat]

Hello,

1. Yeah, I tried with a random sounds, a random decal and random video (roblox owned) from the store and I can see the permission page for all of those
2. I do not (or atleast not to my knowledge, the creator is someone random)
3. Yes, I have permission to edit that experience

Here’s a video showing some random assets (sorry I rushed it to make sure it stayed under the 10MB limit):

[lvyachao (boocatisbest)]

Hi,

OK sounds like your action does not break any existing product behavior:

1. For normal asset, you will need edit permission to sharing permission, yes. However, the ones you are trying is store free asset(Public Domain asset), because target “actor” of experience permission sharing is your experience. It will be same as you click “get Decal” and insert it to your experience, and thus your experience will get the permission.
2. You can only put experience id for the ones you has edit permission. Can tried some random experience id, and you should be denied for that action.

Now I see it’s more like a UI bug, i still need to figure whether you got any special roleset or browser plugin to be able to see this page.

[Sylmat]

Hello,

1. Yeah they’re free assets but permission page should still display a lack of permission instead of the actual page?
2. For experiences I don’t own, the UI works as intended, it tells me that I need permissions to edit the experience to add it, but I can still add my experience there, it doesn’t give any error like it does with Collaborators

So I don’t know if when I put my experience Id and save, if it actually add it to the asset permissions?
Is it something you already checked? That my experience wasn’t added to the asset’s permissions?

[lvyachao (boocatisbest)]

1. It’s still unknown why you can see this permission page, me and my co-workers cannot reproduce it.
2. Yes, experience permission under asset permission page is same as you goes to experience → configure-> permissions to add assetId which you has permission. Both page require you: You has Use permission of this asset AND You has Edit Permission to this experience. Don’t consider it is “adding experience into asset permission”, it’s more like “grant your experience this asset permission to use”.

Why it can works for your experience is everyone has Use permission to public domain(store free) asset.

[Sylmat]

Just noticed I forgot to provide a list of my Firefox extensions and version:
Version 143.0.4 (64-bit)

Otherwise I also have my account since 2009, maybe there are some legacy roles or permissions that I got along the years and for some reasons interfere with that page?

Otherwise is there any network request you want me to track that could help you understand better what’s going on?

[lvyachao (boocatisbest)]

Hi,

Sorry for late response, would you mind check permissions tab under network request? which is calling apis.roblox.com/asset-permissions-api/v1 endpoint.

Noted that this API now always return 200 but from the response, there should be “NoPermission”.

[Sylmat]

Hello!

Filtering on the path you gave me I have 2 request results, the “permissions” one as shown in your screenshot returns 403 for me, there was “check-permissions” which returned 200 with the “NoPermission” as you mentioned, here’s the result of both:

• check-permissions
  

  
  
  
  

• permissions
  

  
  
  
  

Hope this helps!

[lvyachao (boocatisbest)]

Hi,

i think i am close to the root cause, i hope it’s the last question/ask: do you mind also check the network tabs response with /orgs/v1/organizations/, like the screenshot i provide here.

for group owned asset case, there is a separate permission which allow you only view permission tabs but not configure tab.

[Sylmat]

Hello,

here it is:

[lvyachao (boocatisbest)]

Hi Sylmat,

Thanks for your inputs, we has identified the bug, will let you know when fix is ready!

[lvyachao (boocatisbest)]

Hello,
just an update, we had fixed this issue on our side and fix had been released. Pls let us know if this issue still occur to you.

Bests

[Sylmat]

Hello!

I see the “You need permission to access this content” page now for permissions too,

Thanks!