Any tips to get this eerie lighting better?

I’m sorry if this is the wrong Caterogy, but I am trying to achieve a scary/eerie lighting such as this.
image
But I have barely any knowledge on lighting and this is my current progress on the build.
image
So is there any way to make this match the lighting more? Such as any light setting or color correction setting?

why are you making “love Jesus” eerie, isn’t that a bit disrespectful? (Just asking)

To answer your question, try adding fog or just make the environment dark in general.