music doesn’t count as art, music is art by itself.
The latest one seems like it can be good with a gamepass icon or badge icon but, if this would be for a game, you would need to make more of a background.
First:
(This one is awhile ago from photoshop trying to make a gfx

Latest:
(This one was for my group)
As you can tell, I’m not an artist by heart.
They just turned the displacement strength on the modifier too high.
This one is my group icon.
This is my first coolest icon I have ever made
This drawing looks excessively weird, I don’t know how you managed to mess it up. I modified a couple of things while keeping the same drawing. Now you can glimpse how you could have done it.
Changes:
Better shadow placement.
Better positioning.
I hope this will help you enhance in the future.
Um, sir, no one here is asking for feedback on artwork, and quite frankly, its rude to do it without permission.
Also going and “fixing” artwork is heavily looked down upon on the art community.
Please do not do this.
Hey idk if your hireable to make me a gfx but if we could get in contact my discord is EastRequirement#2880
Oh hey! I saw your other post and critiqued it. You’ve gotten really better at gfx! It’s nice to see you improve!
heres an old thumbnail i made for a game
and heres the most recent one i made for the game
But heres one of the first Gfx’s ive done
and heres my most recent one. made 2 hours ago
am i improving?
If you want a GFX, im doing free ones
First
Latest
Version 1.0
Version 2.0
Version 3.0
I have removed the red and blue highlights from Version 2.0 and added light beam dust particles, white highlights, and helicopter light beams. A bullet tracer with a box blur is added to the logo with half-tones.
I also turn the dust, scratches, and dust opacity down from Version 3.0. I also add a movie quote on the top of the movie cover