Made a feature request regarding clipping with layered clothing : Layered clothing should support contextual clipping before it launches
6 Likes
Thanks for the detailed feature request. This is a feature we have been actively discussing and debating within the team. We are looking at ways this can be done automatically without requiring manual tagging of the assets/triangles. Will update in the forum once we have a good solution that is not too hard to author.
14 Likes
Thank you for the update! I’m glad it’s being looked into and am looking forward to hearing about what you folks come up with. 
2 Likes
Because you can use blender for both of those things.
Do you need to skin the clothing before layering it onto the target? I have a rig with a non-skinned mesh that does not work with this feature. It is only when I skin the clothing does it actually layer on.
1 Like
Well that’ll be so good for dismembered…
What’s Dismembered? Never heard of it.
Like cut body parts or limbs off from the person…
1 Like
This morning at ~9am, we will be enabling a change in skinned MeshParts that is necessary for layered clothing, but could temporarily break some scenes using Cage Mesh Deformer Beta. If you notice any problems please let us know. This is only a temporary limitation, we have a fix for Cage Mesh Deformer Beta that we’ll be rolling out in the next few weeks to resolve this completely. Thanks for your hard work and patience.
– Your Roblox Avatar Engineering Team
3 Likes
Yes, the clothing needs to be skinned.
1 Like
Hi! So I did noticed today that the former SurfaceAppearance on the parts, they now break on models, alongside it now adding a bunch of OriginalSize Vector Values.
Though it seemingly works fine when I remove the SurfaceAppearance.
I didn’t particularly need it (or its added functionality) but noticed it was required for the example for the accessory drag n drop to work with our models.
Will it be needed moving forward or do we need to tweak our meshes for this?
New behavior
Hierarchy
w/o the SurfaceAppearance
1 Like
Is this still broken? Or is it working again?
Yes! It now works with and without SurfaceAppearance.
@asmanwoks That’s great. Can you provide us with a test file we can use to debug this? We would still like to understand why it failed.
1 Like
I’m trying to create a character customization menu, but can’t because ViewportFrames do not support caged deformation. It constantly shifts the layers off of the target.
Repo.rbxl (32.1 KB)
3 Likes
With my current understanding of cage mesh deformation, I don’t see a option for soft body deformation, is this an upcoming feature or did I miss anything?
4 Likes
Hello! We’re currently working on making an exciting avatar editor for this technology, however the most recent version of the cage mesh deformer seems to crash quite frequently when we apply our custom mesh to the avatar.
We have two rough prototype characters (to any of my community reading this, these are not final and shouldn’t be viewed as such) which we’re attempting to put a shirt on like so:
As you can see there are a few clipping issues which we’re working to resolve through iterating on the meshes, however half of the time when we place the mesh on the character studio crashes. When it crashes it also seems to corrupt the save, crashing whenever studio attempts to re-open.
RBXL of a recent uncorrupted save (109.5 KB)
Do you know if a more stable build will be coming soon? If there is a problem in our implementation of the mesh would it be possible to help us understand how to avoid it? We’re really excited about this, and we’re looking forward to making a ton of cool characters with it once we’re able to use it!
Thank you for your time!
-CJ
6 Likes
It’s great to see that you’re excited about this feature! This is still a beta implementation, so there are some known issues that we have been steadily fixing, including hidden surface removal and stability improvements. Thanks for your patience with it, and thanks for the repro file.
7 Likes
Are there plans to get Tools working with caged deformation? I’ve been fidgeting around with it and haven’t been able to get it to work.
1 Like
