More information about our DMCA policy

[Sapphitone]

I’m not arguing against that. The claimed content should 100% be deleted. However, as I’ve said, Roblox is under no obligation to terminate users, and the EFF actually discourages a 3 strike system like Roblox is using. By no means do they have to terminate anyone, let alone terminate for old content.

CaptainJadeFlames worded it much better than I could earlier in the thread:

@CaptainJadeFlames

https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2011/01/dmca-copyright-policies-staying-safe-harbors-while

The Electronic Frontier Foundation has made an article regarding safe harbors such as this one. They mention that the DMCA requires handling of the stolen content reasonably, but also mentions the following.

In order to protect their customers’ rights, service providers should avoid knee-jerk and over-simplified policies such as “three strikes (takedown notices) and you’re out.”

While the EFF isn’t exactly the law, I’d imagine if a foundation dedicated to dealing with digital rights for over 25 years, what they have to say here should at least lead to looking into things deeper. Suppose it depends on the details regarding that strike system.