I’d agree under normal circumstances, however, there is an element lost when making a map by hand that really only can be observed in random generation or in nature.
Let’s take those images for example (I have no idea how to quote images). Are they beautiful examples of terrain work? Yes, of course. However, it’s painfully obvious that these are not natural.
a literal 2 paragraph rant about river flow and how it shapes terrain (click to show)
Look at the water in the 2nd image. Which way is it flowing? The bubbles (white lines) go both ways from the waterfall, meaning that the river would not flow. This is also suggested by the way terrain is formed around that area, which implies that water from the waterfall would spread out both ways. Again, none of this would make sense in a flowing river.
As an example, let’s do a comparison. example A is what I believe the terrain looks like in that image. Notice how the water flow makes no sense, assuming the river flows toward the direction of the camera. Now let’s look at example B. The water flow makes sense here, and the terrain follows it. The left corner is sharpened by the flow, while the right one is rounded out. As the water flow merges, it shapes the area around it.
Now, the question is why. Why is this a big deal? I’d argue that this oversight exemplifies the one thing hand-made environments fail at: precisely simulating natural processes. The processes that shape terrain in the real world started thousands of years ago and minor changes to the starting conditions would cause vastly different results.
However, algorithms exist for this purpose. Look up “procedural hydrology” and you’ll see examples of people using water flow to generate terrain. When it comes to natural, realistic terrain, you can outperform a human modeler using an algorithm.
Note: I am speaking about only realism. Game design does not always require ultra-realistic terrain, and more realistic isn’t always better.
3 Likes
Smart. Especially if it’s a GROWING map, inside a already generated server. You should suggest that to Ark Survival Evolved, they’re the guys who are capable to make it while making it still very detailed and autonomous. (We’re not God we can’t compare our work to the nature)
2 Likes
Thanks, I’ll check it out. Looking forward to reading it 
1 Like
If I want to make a rust-style game I will, so far all you’ve said are the buts. But you can’t generate terrain(you can), But it’s not realistic(It’s a goddam test of Perlin noise it’s meant to be as simple as possible), but it’s not as good as hand-built maps(Ok?, do you not realize that’s literally every procedurally generated game(A majority of the content is user generated and I’ve already thought about that. (Persistent server systems))). I got a nice thread from people sharing such useful info so I am quite grateful for you constantly replying and keeping the thread active I truly am thankful 
. You also gave a few valid points and I do plan to take them into account 
4 Likes
Yeah sorry for sounding a bit impatient, anyways, the most difficult part of games like Rust is fixed servers, it means the same server for the player. Ofc he can chose to change one but the player will lose all his current data. In rust, when a player logout his body stays where he was, that would be pretty difficult to do that In roblox especially that the player has to spawn at the same place in the same server maybe 2 weeks after (if still alive)
1 Like
No worries, what you’re speaking of is a persistent server system and I’ve already come up with a system to allow for the persistency of player data independent of other servers.
Option 1
Using private servers. Private servers are unique because they can be identified using Game.PrivateServerId. With this, we can create basic per server saving systems and of course that it also serves as a join code so when users are in the main game they can view recently played servers, favorites, created servers, and of course community servers hosted by other people similar to what is done in games like Islands e.t.c
Links
TeleportService:TeleportToPrivateServer
DataModel.PrivateServerId
Option 2
I think I’m going to keep this one to myself until I work out how it would fully work 
2 Likes
For people in the future using this as a reference there is a small issue you might run into . Good luck finding the solution, I’ll share it once I find out.
1 Like
bro you have got to be kidding me
ofc he wont be able to, b/c that is not what he is going for, its like saying adopt me is unrealistic
well ofc it is not realistic, because its a lowpoly style
And you’re one of the guys who annoyed me in my Creations Feedback post.
2 Likes
lol OG isn’t some noob who wanna make adopt me style, he mentioned the game Rust, it means he’s ambitious and aiming for a high level.
Insult me personally if you want, I don’t wanna get sent into a c- you damn communist
2 Likes
cry about my political views,
ratio+
if he mentioned rust, he used it as an example, he never said he is making the exact detail of that games terrain, its pretty obvious not trying to be mean.
3 Likes
Ask him whether if he’s trying to make a fully pixelated game or a generally realistic one.
2 Likes
It doesn’t matter, it’s just that you automatically assumed and you gave him false criticism
2 Likes
I can’t assume something “automatically” XD
2 Likes
@Officerbruh0987 and @Megalodox_Official please be quiet. You don’t need to drag your argument into every single topic on the forum. If you really want to argue, go do it somewhere else. Thank you.
3 Likes
Yes, you did and it was an off-topic reply.
Plus there are no candles on the floor.
The lighting is fine and it doesn’t look like a ritual.
2 Likes
This link is now a hacked site.
It was… seems like it isnt now.
