Am i good on GFX or not?

Rate these GFX from 10 please, i made them for my HomeStore (game):
the icon:

\

The Thumbnail:


all the Feedbacks are appreciated, Thank You
the homestore:

11 Likes

I’d actually give the icon 8.5/10

The thumbnail is 9/10

So yes, you’re good at making GFXs!

1 Like

Thank you for your feedback, i just started making GFX

2 Likes

Seems like you took a background from google, and slapped a poor cutout of your avatar.

It could be better if the background was from your game, or at least related to your game, and that the avatar was imported into blender to have good lighting and no outline.

2 Likes

oh okay, but sadly i can’t use blender bc my pc is bad :confused:

2 Likes

How about this one? its my group icon

Yeah I would say you are pretty good but always room for improvement but good job :heart:

1 Like

I think you did a really good job! 9/10

– The only thing that needs to be improved is the avatar cropping.
Try using a different background for the avatar (maybe a green screen) and cropping it again…there’s too much white on the avatar to use a white background.

Besides that, really good job!

1 Like

The only thing that needs to be improved is the avatar cropping.

yea i guess i can fix this

1 Like

No, u r not good at making GFX, try more and get better.

3 Likes

It just seems ok, The lighting dose not fit that well And the background is just out of place, Still better then what i can do tho.

2 Likes

You are pretty ok at making GFX. Tho the avatar’s backround is still showing a bit. I’ll rate this an 6/10 :+1:

2 Likes

okay, i appreciate any tips that can make me better on making GFX (i dont have blender)

1 Like

Practice makes perfect, instead of going in a game to get a cutout, go in studio and take a full 1920x1080 picture by going in test - device - hd 1080 - physical size, then take a screenshot with the studios screenshot feature, also make sure to add a ton of effects, try to shy away from basic text too. here is a piece that i made, WITHOUT blender. and i did this on a old pc with intel hd graphics
:slight_smile:

2 Likes

I rate these GFXs 8/10. You should make it seem like the character is in the scene more.

1 Like

okay thanks for the tips imma go practice more

I’m sorry, but it seems like you need to work on your graphics skills. However, don’t worry, I can give you some advice on what can help you improve.

Here’s what you might be doing:
1. You take a picture of your avatar while in-game or use Roblox Studio.
2. After taking the picture or importing your avatar into Roblox Studio, you might use an AI website to remove the background.
3. Then, you go to an editing software and add a simple stroke and font.
4. Finally, you choose a random image from Google to use as a background.

Now, this is what professionals do:
They export their avatar file and import it into Blender, which is a software used for 3D modelling, animation, and graphics.
After importing their avatar into Blender, they give it the best possible pose and check the angles for rendering the image, which will be best for their icon, thumbnail, and other graphics.
Once they have chosen the best angle, they render the image and use good editing software like Photoshop. If you cannot afford Photoshop, you can use Photopea, which is a free alternative.
Afterwards, they edit the image further to make it look more professional.

I hope this helps you understand the difference between what you are doing and what professionals do.

1 Like

Actually looks like a solid GFX, though if you want some feedback.

First off, the white outline around the avatar looks a little awkward and the font could use a bit more styling.
The text font is fine, but I would perhaps give it a gradient or use some colors/effects to make it match the background and rest of the image a bit better while still popping out and being readable.

1 Like

okay thank you, but i didnt say i am profissional, also i can’t use blender on my pc :confused:

well I didn’t say you are professional, I was just letting you know how professionals do there work.

1 Like