Archived posts should not be able to be flagged

I think that if an inappropriate post was already resolved by a Community Sage - for example, a post getting archived because it discussed a topic that was resolved already, it should not be able to be flagged. Why? Well, here’s my case:

I accidentally posted something in a different category. After noticing, I immediately replied, saying that I posted it in the wrong category and that I request the post to be deleted/moved. 2 hours later, an CS actually went and archived the post. But a day after that, I got told that my post was flagged. I tried discussing that my post was already removed by a CS, but I only got (what I think was) a canned response which didn’t mention anything about how my post got already removed before being flagged.

So, I suggest locking the Flag option if a post has been archived. If a post is archived, it usually means that it had already been resolved by a Community Sage.

Well, maybe locking the Flag option entirely isn’t a good idea, but I haven’t thought about any other prevention of these cases.

This cannot be done by Roblox. You can suggest this in Discourse Meta - the official forum for Discourse which is used by Roblox to make this forum.

2 Likes

If the post is archived nobody will bother flagging it because action has already been taken. This is a non-issue.

Yes it can. But usually core discourse features aren’t modified.

Note that my post got flagged after it got archived.

If it was to point where a sage had to archive a post then it deserves any and all flags it gets. Not talking about you only. In general.

Posts can be archived only by CS’s. Or at least I don’t see any archive options. And I also requested deletion of my post.

So what’s the issue? Why shouldn’t we be able to flag after archiving? Don’t get me wrong, but flagging seems to be a solution to get rid your misplaced post.

1 Like

UPDATE: I requested this on Discourse Meta, this is what I got from staff:

This basically sums it up. Discourse won’t add it because it interferes with other features and is such an uncommon issue.

1 Like