Arguments vs Parameters: Why Understanding the Difference Matters

Hello ROBLOXIAN(s)!

As many of you know, when learning how to script (whether you’re starting with Roblox or any other language), there are certain concepts that, although seemingly basic, can make a huge difference in how we understand code. One of the most commonly misunderstood concepts in programming is the difference between arguments and parameters.

What’s the difference?

  • Arguments are the values you provide when calling a function.
  • Parameters are the variables a function uses to accept the arguments.

Here’s an example to break it down:

function greet(name)  -- "name" is a parameter
    print("Hello, " .. name)
end

greet("Smurf")  -- "Alice" is an argument

In the example above:

  • name is the parameter in the function definition.
  • "Alice" is the argument passed when calling the function.

Why does it matter?

It might seem like a small detail, but understanding the distinction is important, especially as you progress as a scripter. Here are a few reasons:

  1. Clarity: Knowing the terms lets you understand and explain your code more clearly.
  2. Communication: When you’re reading online tutorials or forums (like this one), understanding common terms ensures you don’t get confused when you’re troubleshooting or looking up information.
  3. Efficiency: Recognizing these concepts early on will help you avoid confusion later when dealing with more complex topics.

Key Takeaways:

  • Parameters define what data the function expects when declared.
  • Arguments are the data values you pass when you call the function.

This distinction will come up often as you get deeper into scripting, especially when working with functions, methods, and more advanced topics like classes and objects.

This topic was a thorn in my side, caused confusion and stunted my growth as a scripter.

I want to make sure that doesn’t happen to someone else.

Poll: Test Your Knowledge!

To make sure you’re on the right track, let’s do a quick poll to see how well everyone understands the difference between arguments and parameters. You’ll see a question below with a test scenario—choose the correct answer!

Question: In the following code, which term applies to "5"?

function multiply(number)
    return number * 2
end

multiply(5)
  • A) Argument
  • B) Parameter

0 voters

7 Likes

Been programming for 5 years and used these words interchangeably. It really doesn’t matter, everybody knows what you mean.

9 Likes

Thanks for engaging with the post, and I appreciate your perspective. I understand where you’re coming from—after programming for several years, it’s easy to assume that terms like “arguments” and “parameters” are interchangeable. However, for those who are just starting to learn how to script, it’s important to make that distinction clear early on.

When we’re learning, every little bit of clarity counts. The difference between arguments (the values we pass to functions) and parameters (the variables that receive those values) might seem small, but understanding it helps with writing more understandable and maintainable code in the long run.

While experienced developers may instinctively know what you mean, beginners are still building that foundation, and being specific with terms will help them get comfortable with the language and better understand more complex topics later on.

Again, I appreciate your comment, and I hope you can see how this post is aimed at making sure newer users have a solid foundation as they continue to learn and grow! :blush:

Still getting used to DevForum, I wanted to reply [-_-] and ended up posting.

4 Likes

Why not only the post but your response feel like chat gpt lol

5 Likes

3 Likes

Ai detection isnt accurate. It can detect things such as “The declaration of independece”- USA as fully AI.

All its actually doing is checking for high level grammar and articulation. There is no methodical way to detect if something was written by AI besides perceiving it being written by the AI.

This is due to the nature of language models such as chatgpt and others.

All im saying is, yes since it says 75% there is a chance. But this detection website doesnt mean anything in the long run.

2 Likes

Thing is no one really says “Thanks for engaging with the post” and then starts explaining what the person just said with extreme level grammar

2 Likes

People only use an AI text detector when they themselves think it was AI generated. Humans are usually better detectors of behavior than robots, I think. If you’re a robot though, please do inform me of how your species has evolved! :+1:

2 Likes

First of all, you used ChatGPT and replaced “Alice” with “Smurf” but forgot to change the footnote beside it.

Second, it is inherently obvious you have no idea what you’re talking about.

Third, parameters in luau are placeholders and an argument is the actual value. For example, “name” is the placeholder but “Alice” is the actual name, therefore the actual value. Hope this clears things up.

2 Likes

I don’t like that every person who tries to do something on the forum is criticized for any indicator that indicates a use of ChatGPT (keeping in mind that it can be a false positive) I think the capable guy tried to do the best he could, or I don’t know, but it must not have been with bad intentions.

Greetings

1 Like

I literally pulled up ChatGPT on my phone and found the exact words and examples they used in their post. I didn’t use an AI detector.

2 Likes

The exact moment I read the “why it matters” bullet points and “Key Takeaways” section I immediately knew this is ChatGPT-generated nonsense. Don’t even need an AI detector website to realize it, once you’ve used ChatGPT for a bit you just sort of learn and internalize the weird way it talks and formats its messages. It’s really obvious. Roblox should really consider cracking down on AI-generated posts. This isn’t a tutorial or a resource, it’s just clutter.

As others have previously mentioned, this is useless ChatGPT rambling.

For any inspiring scripters reading, don’t acknowledge this post. This is not valuable information and will not help you in the long run.

1 Like

Clarifying the Process Behind the Post

I’d like to address some concerns and walk you through the process I used to create this post to clarify how much of it reflects my own ideas versus where I used tools like ChatGPT for assistance.

Transparency is important, and I want to ensure there are no misunderstandings about my intentions or methods.


Step 1: Concept and Ideas

The topic of arguments vs parameters was entirely my own idea. It came from my personal struggles as a scripter when I first encountered these concepts. I wanted to create something that could help newer scripters avoid the confusion I went through.


Step 2: Drafting and Planning

I drafted the initial ideas and key points, such as:

  • Explaining the difference between arguments and parameters.

  • Highlighting why understanding this distinction is important for scripting.

  • Including examples and polls for interactivity.

These ideas were entirely mine, stemming from my experience and my desire to create an engaging learning resource.


Step 3: Refining with ChatGPT

Once I had my draft, I used ChatGPT as a tool to:

  • Check grammar and improve readability.

  • Suggest better ways to format the post to meet DevForum standards (e.g., how to use markdown for polls).

  • Help me refine explanations to make them more beginner-friendly.

I want to emphasize that the content, structure, and intent of the post were my own.

The AI assisted me with phrasing and formatting, but I was in full control of the process and the ideas behind it.


At the end of the day, it’s about promoting growth, discussion, and a healthy atmosphere where we can all improve together.

This post was created to assist newer developers, just as I would have wanted when I was starting out.

Not to talk about the application of AI within forums.

Thanks for engaging with my post.

2 Likes

So to summarize, you gave chatgpt two or three points to go off of and then pasted what it spat out.

The discouragement towards this post is outrageous!

No we’re not moving off topic onto builders club now as well.

The original post was created with intentions for follow up polls, with more questions and I had the abysmal expectation being…

we could at least stay on topic!

  • Correction AI was utilised for grammar correction, punctuation checks.

  • To create a sharper narrative, getting to the point faster:

  • Learning shortcuts, such as bullet points and other forum related structuring methods such as polls.

The ideas, “why it’s important” section, relative responses where my own.

Ending the conversation in relevance to AI; I’m open to suggestions, changes, contributions towards the topic such as new additions(your own polls, questions you think would be better suited) or questions relative to gathering information relating to the topic.

If you want to debate the usage of AI within DevForum, create another thread, thank you.

1 Like

I’ll often use the terms “argument” and “parameter” interchangeably. However, I do think there’s significance in knowing the difference. I’ve been programming for well over a decade and just realized the other day that I had actually flipped the definitions of the two in my head at some point.

While I appreciate your transparency on use of AI, (whether they were the result of AI or not) there’s a few points that may be worth changing to improve the resourcefulness of the original post:

  • As @DonaldDuck5150 mentioned, you claim that “Alice” is the argument in the comment and notes below the code block, however the code has “Smurf” as the argument.
  • Your definition of parameters is: “the variables a function uses to accept the arguments”. This relies on the definition of “argument” to define “parameter”. It may be better to define both without a reliance on the other when looking to clarify the difference between them. For example, “Parameters are the variables found in a function signature”
  • This last one is definitely a nit-pick: In the poll section of the original post you ask, “…which term applies to "5"?” I read this formatting as the string with character ‘5’ due to the use of double quotes. I would instead simply format it as 5 since the code block below intends for the value to be a number.