Audio Moderation Issue

On audios which have a certain amount of plays or that are uploaded by certain accounts, reports are not sent through when you report the audios. This happens on multiple systems.

Expected behavior

I expect all reports on audios to be reviewed no matter how many plays the audio has or who uploaded it.

2 Likes

Hi @weselito, thanks for filing a bug report.

Could you provide some example audio assets that you cannot report so we can take a closer look? As well, where are you trying to report these audio assets from (eg website, app, in a game, etc).

It appears you cannot report any audios uploaded by APMOfficial. If I try to report an inappropriate audio, there are no visible error messages. It just does not appear to get sent to be reviewed. I am attempting to report on the website.

Hi @weselito,

On our side we have confirmed that reports on audio uploaded by the APMOfficial account are being created and reviewed by moderators. Could it be that the reports you submitted were denied? If you have the asset id of a specific track you reported I can take a closer look.

I am referring to this audio as it has a few sexually suggestive references and references getting high.

1 Like

Reports against certain whitelisted content are (“seemingly”) automatically thrown out/ignored (verified games/groups/accounts, star creators, high value accounts like rich traders)

1 Like

This seems to be true. I feel like users who submit hundreds of reports that have been approved should be granted some sort of backend feature to have reports always sent to a human and never be thrown out.

Nope, reports go through for “protected users”. It’s just audio moderation that’s bad, I could easily find is this open on catalog of some tts just saying racial slurs: https://create.roblox.com/store/asset/122713030894416/maman
https://create.roblox.com/store/asset/80562544662372/-
https://create.roblox.com/store/asset/125913445304133/-
https://create.roblox.com/store/asset/87425483368157/-
https://create.roblox.com/store/asset/133547302586127/-
https://create.roblox.com/store/asset/70377945513952/-
https://create.roblox.com/store/asset/107805319224043/Daniel-Larson-Edit
https://create.roblox.com/store/asset/109928599658229/id-like-to-solve-the-puzzle
https://create.roblox.com/store/asset/80831446203156/sparkles
https://create.roblox.com/store/asset/106458852034244/oghhg
https://create.roblox.com/store/asset/91774295020768/099-distortion
https://create.roblox.com/store/asset/77654571919360/Printer-SFX
https://create.roblox.com/store/asset/73766072078589/SlipSfx
(I can find hundreds more of those, honestly gonna do it, i wont add more it’s not going to be taken care of anyway)

Additionally main games of those type of people still seem to be up after years:

So are the groups owned by the malicious people:
group-list (1).txt (6.0 KB)
Example:

Audio doesn’t seem to be moderated, bypasses still exist and whatever else. I’ve tried reporting them hundreds of times.

I’m gonna go through and report these hoping that they get taken down.

Good luck, tried that before, groups, games, and audio are up, even after almost a year and a half of actively reporting them.

I really hope I become one of these people so my audio reports get sent through. When I report audios I have barely any luck getting them taken down.

After a few minutes it appears some of the ones I reported did actually get taken down. Maybe my reports do get reviewed now.

I’m reporting those actively right now with @PetrTechDev and we got some deleted today. Except any reports towards groups or games never goes through.

I have reported groups for things and group reports seem to go through just fine for me. I recently reported a bunch of group names I found which violated the Community Standards and tons of the names got reset.

1 Like

The issue is that those groups are actively powering Roblox’s audio bypassing scene, they all need to be locked not reset.

I’ll report these groups. I’ll try getting them locked.

1 Like

I checked this audio and see some abuse reports for this song. This song is still up because our human moderators have rejected each abuse report meaning the song is allowed on Roblox.

I’m going to close this report since the original bug report has been confirmed to be working and the conversation is going off topic. Please continue to report audio files that violate Roblox’s terms and our moderators will take a look.