Hey everyone, i’m Yor_ick. A builder and a modeler.
Today i want you to rate and give feedback on my sword that i’ve made in blender.
I like it alot but i feel like it could be better. I trust the Devforum and think it is really useful!
here is a picture of it:
Be honest and say what you want about it and how i can improve for next time.
Feedback
Overall, it is a good sword. It possesses an accurate rain-guard , fuller and such. Though I do spot some inconsistencies.
It could use a central ridge.
is the tip you gonna in UGC or you have no access to that yet.
Looks excellent. Not really any changes come to mind when viewing this.
Looks really nice. I think it looks nice as it is now, being quite simple and plain, rather than it being really detailed.
Good luck!
i’m confused on what you’re trying to say
To what I can see is that you mixed both flat and smooth shading together, and that isn’t ideal. If you want the have the smooth cuts but the edges not looking weird, just make it smooth shade, add an edge split modifier, and mess around with the degrees.
Hope this helps!
I think adding a leather-like wrapping around the handle would work well.
This was the best example I could find.
I am not 100% sure if you subdivided the handle or if you have smooth shading on it, but if its smooth shading, do the same to the blade and in the normals options, turn on auto-smooth and adjust the angle value to better match your blade 
. p.s. if your handle is subdivided, I strongly urge you to use smooth shading on it instead with a lower poly handle as subdivide is mostly for making high-poly assets that are meant to be baked onto the low poly ones, which is not in roblox, YET ;).
It looks excellent. The handle grip could be edited a bit but otherwise it looks great!
