I recently made a UI and I am looking for feedback to make it better. I am trying to achieve a main menu UI like Fifa.
3 Likes
That’s super nice, did you make the gfx?
I was gonna make it but I didn’t have enough time. I will make it once I have enough time. The current one was made by my friend for me.
Nice!
30 characters breakdown aah
1 Like
I like what you’re going for, maybe try making the border glow?
1 Like
Would it look better if it glows on selection or if it glows always?
On selection, really stands out but that’s my opinion. You may have something else in mind.
1 Like
From the looks of it, it is very plain. The background is a little too noticeable and distracting for me (I am extremely picky with small details). I do not think that the transparency is needed on the gray buttons. I would suggest adding an English Translation to your UI as well. I enjoy the sprite sheet, but why the color yellow and gray together? Gray is more of a subtle color while yellow is bright and in-your-face. The GFX on the top right is very plain considering the GFX on the left has more action going on.
My biggest tip for people who ask for feedback is to look at everything in the player’s perspective. When I first look at the UI, I look for the things that pop-out to me. The different sizing of text is sorta-disappointing.
Sprite sheets. I love when people use sprite sheets. Everything just forms into life that way. I feel as if the transition point is too long and a player does not want to wait for it to turn yellow. They player (most likely) wants to jump right into the game. Nobody wants to wait for the GUI to finish loading.
I would suggest adding a border. Using apps like Photoshop really can help your UI become better. Adding a simple glow to your UI or moving the UI to the right and down can really make a large difference.
Please, do note that I have never played Fifa. I do not know what the menus are or want to look like. I would suggest adding a picture of what you are trying to achieve next to your link.
Everything that I have stated in this message is all based on my opinion and first looks. You should not feel disheartened about anything I have said (and yes, I have to put this in here because many will be disheartened). Never give up on your talent for UI designing. One day you will become the next best developer (or in this case, UI designer). Sitting and doing nothing will never get you to the place you would like to be. You have so much potential and I’m sure this game will go places.
Sincerely,
FallinqSnowFlake 
1 Like
Thank you a lot for your feedback. The reason I am not adding English Translation is this game is for a Turkish Group and I don’t think it is needed to have an English Translation. In addition you can actually just click the button without waiting for it to turn yellow. I agree with all of the other things you say and I will try to make it better based on your suggestions.
1 Like