Could I get feedback on this project?
I love music, so a giant playable keyboard seemed like a great idea for a first project.
I went for realism rather than functionality so the actual gameplay might be kind of glitchy.
Keep in mind its the first thing game I’ve ever posted so its going to be really bad.
11 Likes
This is a super awesome first project! They keyboard was excellently modeled and the detail you put into it is superb! My only gripe would be that the keys don’t resonate once released and instead are instantly cut short. Consider a delay!
Awesome stuff man, excited to see what you make in the future!
1 Like
Thank you very much for checking it out! I appreciate the feedback. I agree, the audio does not sound like a real piano because it just :stop()s the audio right when you release. I will definitely work on making it more smooth. 
2 Likes
One thing I would say is that in an actual keyboard, if you press a key and let go really fast, the tone doesn’t instantly cut off.
Also,the W and S key are used to play the keyboard but also move the camera.
That’s a little troublesome.
Those are some things you could improve.
Other than that, this is an awesome first game!
1 Like
Thanks for the feedback!
The instant cutoff is something I plan to fix ASAP. If you press shift it locks the camera so that it does move when your try it play. I put the controls to this in the description!
1 Like
You should disable the W and S key for movement, whenever you click the two keys while playing the piano, it moves your screen. Another thing is the intro it isn’t scaled correctly, a huge portion of the UI is missing, you should scale it to where it fits the whole screen. For a first project this is fantastic, great job!
1 Like
You can lock the camera so that it is not movable by pressing shift. But I think I will change the camera movement to the arrow keys to get rid of all confusion. How is the ui messed up? Could you maybe send me some pics of what is like for you if it’s not to much trouble? The ui is all fine on my screen. Hmm…
1 Like
It’s not that big of a deal, but even if it is suppose to look like this it doesn’t look right. I’m talking about the loading UI with the white background, a whole portion of it’s missing on the right and bottom of the screen.
WOOOOOOO… Idk why this its happening but I’ll try and fix it asap. Thanks for the help!
I might have fixed it. Could you maybe check one more time? The glitch have been related to screen size, for this is what it looked like for me:
It’s no longer occurring to me but the “The Keyboard” UI is more over to the left side than yours. Rather than being over the Loading text.
Intersting… Do you know how I might fix this?
Well, there’s multiple tutorials on youtube that you can find to fix this issue, and there’s also a popular plugin that I cannot find right now. Another thing you could do if those both don’t work, you can ask around on the devforum.
Thanks so much dude! I really appreciate the help!
I tried using UiAspectRatioConstraints to fix the problem. Could you see If its fixed one last time?
It’s fixed. Glad it worked out for you!
3 Likes